618. SOCIAL JUSTICE IN SOCIALISM

                                         618.  SOCIAL JUSTICE IN SOCIALISM.

/

 Since 2002, I am trying very hard, on the base of Marxism, to change the party's stance of promoting capitalism. The CPI(M) Politburo was not willing to deviate even slightly from its stance of promoting capitalism. So many party congresses have over. Marxism is the philosophy for fighting against capitalism. Even though the party that existed in 2002 has ceased to exist, the party is making moves to eliminate what is still exists. The CPI(M) and CPI has a firm stance that there is no need for Marxism; the leadership will not accept socialism under any circumstances.

The fact that "socialism" is not accepted as a party program by CPI(M), CPI means that the "GOVERNMENT", which is the cause of oppression by the bourgeoisie, should not to the working class. It also shows in its actions that it does not accept Marxism. It should also be remembered that this is a matter for a party with a hundred years of history.

//

If the country is rich, the people will get all the benefits. The position of the capitalists and bourgeois political parties is that this should never happen. That is the reason for the Congress and BJP's stance that public sector industries should not be allowed under any circumstances. The profits from public sector enterprises go to the nation. We can use it to run hospitals, educational institutions and the development of the country. That should not be the case. Corruption is not possible there. Election funds will not be received from there. That is the reason for the bourgeois parties' stance that there should be no public property for any reason. If wealth is in the hands of the capitalists, then its dominance -- that is capitalism. State ownership of wealth - that is the basis of socialism. That is the reason why bourgeois political parties take the position that socialism should not be allowed under any circumstances. China, a socialist country, is strong because wealth is in the hands of the "STATE".

// 

The social justice as well as facts proving the scientific base of Marxism, are shared through social media for the knowledge of ordinary people. Unfortunately, none of them even remotely convincing to the Communist leadership in India.  My intention through my posts is that the Communist Parties in India should ask the people to vote for a socialist society. Along with that, the CPI(M) and CPI party comrades and leaders must consider what actually democracy is. But despite all this; it has been presented for many years, none of it comes to the attention of the CPI(M); CPI party leadership. The Communist parties in India (CPI(M); CPI) are moving forward with the approach that there is no such thing as socialism other than capitalism in India. Even if Lenin's words that without socialist ideas; Marxist ideas will be buried become true, it is not an issue for the party leadership. The situation of the CPI, which has entered into an alliance with the Indian National Congress, and the disappearance of communist parties across India are not issues for the (CPI(M); CPI) parties. They will not change their stance of promoting capitalism. The only issue is that party leaders should continue in leadership until the maximum age. They have no responsibility to the people who put their faith in the Communist Party - or to the more than one hundred and thirty crore people in India who are not capitalists. This is evident from the stance that even if the socialist system accepted by Marxism is part of the Indian Constitution, the people will not be asked to vote for its implementation.Things are going to turn out that they are unable to adapt to socialism because they have only dealt with the capitalist system for a long time. Those who say so have nothing else to say except the stand by the words of EMS, "The party has never said anywhere that socialism can be established through parliamentary means." There is no other way for social change before humanity than the democratic means.

//

When there was a dispute over accepting "SOCIALISM" as "Party Program", as Pre-revolutionary Russia was industrially backward, Lenin said that not accepting SOCIALISM would only bury "Marxist ideology". The reason was if SOCIALISM not the target, Marxist ideology cannot exist, because it is the weapon of the working class' for establishing "socialism." That' is the reason to write the work "What should be done?". That's where the relevance of socialist ideology should not be underestimated even a little bit. The acceptance of Lenin's words in Russia led to the formation of the Soviet Union, which helped spread socialism throughout the world. What Lenin pointed out happened in India. Lenin said that if socialism is not accepted, Marxist ideology will only be buried, which is exactly what happened in India.

//

Even if "socialism" is accepted as "Party Program", it will be very difficult to convey its scientific nature and social justice to the working class and ordinary people. Even then, since they are purely social justice, the vast majority of people with good intentions will accept them. But the position of the Communist Party leadership is that there is no such thing as "socialism"  in India.   They want only to restore the "CONGRESS RULE" again in India under the banner "SECULAR INDIA", even which is impossible because INC want only "COMMUNIST FREE INDIA" along with "RAM RAJ".   The scientific nature of socialism is that the vast majority of society participates in the production of all essential goods, including agricultural products. Therefore, all those who participate in it deserve to live free from poverty and suffering. But the position of those who stand for capitalism is that no one in society should live without poverty and suffering, for whatever reason. Those who oppose socialism will be very little if they understand the basic facts. The advantage of democracy over the old monarchies is that it allows the people to be informed about everything.

//

This does not change the stance of handing over the ruling of India to the Indian National Congress to end the Hindutva extremists' reign of terror in India. The results of the 2019 and 2024 Parliament elections teach them nothing. The Communist Party leadership also fails to understand that the Indian National Congress's stance is that socialist ideas and working-class politics should disappear from India. Even though I, as an ordinary Indian citizen, have freedom of speech and political freedom, I cannot change the stance of the Communist Party leadership. The purpose of all my posts on social media is to appeal to the people to vote for a socialist system that also recognizes the Indian Constitution. Therein lies the danger of sticking to the words of the EMS that "the party has nowhere said that socialism can be established by parliamentary means." If the Communist parties in India (CPI(M); CPI) are not ready to admit democracy and get peoples verdict for a socialist country, the Communist movement in India will not be able to move forward for long. The party that existed in the 1950s no longer exists in India. The party that existed in West Bengal no longer exists. The party does not know why it disappeared. Nobody know why the party hasn't grown in other states in India. In Kerala, there is no real working class politics except "development". They are adamant on the position that there are no class enemies. "If the socialist system is not accepted as a "party program", then Marxist ideas will only be buried" (LENIN). Even though the words of Lenin's "What should be Done?" have been became true in India for the past 75 years since 1950, the leadership of the Communist Party of India (CPI(M) and CPI(M) is not convinced. If don't accept socialism, it only means, don't accept Marxism. 

//

The working class and the common people must be convinced of the scientific nature and social justice of socialism. But for that the leadership of the CPI(M) and CPI Communist Party should be convinced that the target of socialism is necessary. They fail to understand from long-standing experience that Marxist ideas cannot survive without the goal of socialism. That is what is happening in India right now. If anything doesn't grow and spread means only not alive. The life of a COMMUNIST PARTY is MARXIST IDEOLOGY. It requires only for SOCIALIST society. When neglected SOCIALISM, the COMMUNIST PARTY in India is at present not ALIVE.   

//

Karl Marx, who was aware of the hard work and hardships of working people, dedicated his life to it, gave form to the philosophy of Marxism, and wrote the work "Capital". But none of that matters relevant to the leadership of the CPI(M) and CPI Communist Party of India. Consider politics as just a part of their existence and continue in leadership until to reach their maximum age. That is the basis of the position that the BJP's rule end in Indian politics is all that is needed. From past experience, we can understand that the end of BJP rule is not an important issue for them. The Indian National Congress is a bourgeois political party that has ruled India for a very long time and their stance is the working-class politics should not exist in India for any reason is not an issue to Communist Party leadership. They also fail to understand that wherever Communist Party candidates contest in India, Congress and all reactionaries, including the BJP, unite to defeat them.

//

The primary justice and foundation of socialism is to transform the economic laws of the old monarchy into democratic ones. In the monarchy that existed for a very long time, matters were decided solely according to the king's interests. In democracy, political power is equal for all citizens. The Indian Constitution should also be amended accordingly.

//

Social justice in socialism is not only just liberation from the exploitations of labor power experienced by the working class along with spiritual exploitation. Without understanding the social justice of socialism, it is impossible to defend Brahminism and its monstrous form, the Chaturvarnya system. It is impossible to counter all communal arguments without conveying to the people the Marxist view that all are human. The country's economic laws, which have been part of a long-standing monarchy, also need to be changed by the people in democracy. The four-caste system of Brahmin superamacy was implemented by the kings. According to Manusmriti, the "Brahmin Sabha" could decide what the "KING" not able to decide. That is why the BJP Government is challenging even the Supreme Court. The Narendra Modi administration had no difficulty in overturning the Supreme Court's Constitution Bench's decision that the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court should be involved in deciding the Election Commission. When they decide on an Election Commission that fully accepts the decisions of the Sangh Parivar, they are able to implement elections across India according to the decisions of the Sangh Parivar. People's democracy can only be established in socialism. The people have the eligibility to enjoy all the natural resources of the country. In a democracy, the majority of the people can decide matters. There was no opportunity for that in the monarchy. If there is majority in Parliament, amendments that apply to the entire country are also possible in the Constitution. Education, denied to the vast majority under monarchy, can only be made available to all under SOCIALISM.

//

 When  saying that "The Indian National Congress" cannot save India from the "Hindutva BJP" just because they are the same on issues like Ram Rajya, economic policies, corruption, anti-women policy etc. Just like AAP leader Kejriwal was imprisoned, the Amit Shah-Modi regime will put Rahul Gandhi and Sonia Gandhi in jail at any time. Modi has the tools for that. Modi-Shah will use the facts of their forty-eight-hour interrogation at any time. Rahul Gandhi also knows that. Rahul-Sonia always do everything with that in mind. That is why Congress deliberately handed over the Delhi government to the BJP in the Delhi Assembly elections held in February 2025. They only move like that at any moment.

//

Without contesting "LEFT" Parties  each and every  elections held anywhere in India, cannot  disclose the alterations of voting machines by the BJP. There is "left" enough for that in India. All it needs to do is abandon the promotion of capitalism and accept the Indian Constitution, democracy, and socialism. "Hooliganism" is not part of democracy or nature of Indian Constitution. Indian democracy cannot be protected without dealing with the anti-democratic "hooliganism" carried out by the Sangh Parivar in the same way.

/

FOR ENTRUSTING THE RULING OF INDIA TO INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS, NOBODY WILL VOTE FOR "LEFT," IN KERALA OR ANYWHERE IN INDIA. BESIDES, TO DEFEAT "RED FLAG CANDIDATES" THE UNITY OF INC, BJP AND ALL THE REACTIONARY FORCES OF THE WORLD WILL BE A FACT. BUT MARXISM IS ENOUGH AND MORE, IF SOCIALISM WITH IT TO HANDLE EVERYBODY ONLY WITH IDEOLOGICALLY.

//

"The Party has never said anywhere that socialism can be established through parliamentary means" and "The free development of capitalist society" is the refuge found by those who adhere to the words of EMS. They don't understand that the current situation in West Bengal is a result of that. They only know how to utter words without knowing the meaning. Along with that, we must add Sitaram Yechury's words, "Only the Indian National Congress can save India." No matter what a "Harihara Kurup" says, it will not change the stance of those who stand by the words of EMS. EMS nowhere says what the status of the Communist Party in India should be. Harihara Kurup will not have the opportunity to say a single word except through social media. No one will see it. In India, the repetitions of what the Sangh Parivar showed in Gujarat in 2002 will continue. The resolutions protesting the CPI(M) PB will also continue as usual without any intention. No one knows that the "Indian Constitution" is just a piece of waste paper for the Sangh Parivar.

//

The position adopted by the CPI(M) at its 22nd, 23rd, and 24th Party Congresses was to defeat the BJP in India and hand over the governance of India to the Indian National Congress. For that, people should vote for Congress. The experience of the 22nd and 23rd party congresses was also a failure. The CPI(M) was experiencing setbacks. Because no one will vote for the Communist Party to hand over the governance of India to the Indian National Congress. But the CPI(M) leadership was not convinced. It adopted the same stance at the next party congress also. Because the Left will not have candidates across India. People who are tired of voting for Congress will not vote again. Since the Left does not have candidates to govern India, they will not vote for the CPM either. In effect, the Sangh Parivar regime will continue in India. The Left is also asking for votes for the same economic policies of the Congress and the BJP. For the complete transfer of national wealth to Corporates, the complete privatization of public sectors, and complete ban on permanent postings in all field, for universalizing corruption and all the anti-social positions of the Congress. the Left also will seek votes from the peoples. (None of that will be an issue in the elections.) In Kerala, only "development" will be the issue in the parliamentary elections. The entire India, BJP, Congress and all other reactionaries will unite against the Left. There will be no political change in India without the Left asking for votes for the socialist system. That is where the stance of the the free growth of capitalist society of the country will become an issue. The situation of the Left will be pathetic in the next parliamentary elections as well because for the ruling of Indian National, Congress, nobody will vote for "LEFT" as happened in Kerala in the past and the country as a whole. And also, there are no change of economic policies in the part of "LEFT". The BJP will pass a resolution in Parliament declaring the "Indian Constitution" is set aside. Even if socialism is accepted, it will take some time to bring it to the people. But the CPI(M) leaders do not know that. Prakash Karat and others will never allow the party program to change. Central Committee members who know nothing will just applaud everything.

//

What the Communist leaders of the 1950s, Comrades K. Damodaran and EMS, did not understand was not only that the entire written history was history of class struggles. contradiction-based materialism and class antagonisms, but also Marx's fundamental discovery is that the environment determines consciousness; consciousness does not determine the environment. Part of that is the discovery that a country's economic system deciding its political and cultural superstructure. These matters were made clear in the work "A Contribution to Political Economy", which Marx prepared before writing "Das Capital". This issue was presented distortedly in K. Damodaran's "Marxist Classes". But that Comrade did not understand the issue. Otherwise, he would not have decided to promote Indian capitalism, which was built on Brahminism and feudalism. The monarchy was maintained by feudal lords. The capitalist system is maintained by capitalists or their money power. In India, it is the Indian National Congress and the BJP that protect Indian Corporates. In return, they will protect the Congress and the BJP. But no matter how much the Communist Party takes the stance that capitalism should grow, the Corporates, Congress, and BJP will not allow the Communist Party to survive in India. The philosophy of "Marxism" is entirely designed to establish all of this. It is quite natural that Pinarayi Vijayan, Prakash Karat, or Sitaram Yechury do not understand things that comrades K Damodaran and EMS do not understand. But what happens when we ignore the specific points made in all of Lenin's works is what is happening to the Communist Party of India, which has a history of over a hundred years.

//

It is also impossible to convince party leaders that it was against which social system Marxist ideas were formed and that it was that system they decided to promote. It is don't know which social system have to be promote and which should be defeated. There are very few people in society who even understand anything. The vast majority are those who imitate others. The end of the long-standing monarchy and the advent of democracy are completely new circumstances. Those who should be teaching about the new circumstances are stuck in the old ones. That's what happened when they decided to promote "capitalism."

//

Anybody those who can't understand any ideas, will not convince how such ideas will work in people. So nobody can convince them how socialist ideas will work among the peoples. If SOCIALISM admitting as PARTY PROGRAM, above 90% peoples will co-operate with socialist ideology, because SOCIALISM is only natural justice and protecting those actually creating the wealth of the nation. Unfortunately nothing can convince the COMMUNIST PARTY LEADERS OF INDIA. If the party's political goal is a socialist system, then its foundation will be the common people, including the working class and farmers. They will protect that system. They will have the complete philosophy of Marxism to give them spiritual strength. That is what Lenin said: "While the working class finds its spiritual strength in philosophy, philosophy finds its material strength in the working class."

//

What is spiritual exploitation?

??

Spiritual exploitation is worse than the economic exploitation suffering by the working class. The basis of spiritual exploitation is that life on earth is not real life; real life is after death. Through this, the exploiting classes make man willing to endure anything. This is the position of all religions. In the "Mahabharata" story, the justification for killing everyone in the "Kurukshetra War" is not the material life in earth is "truth", but real life is after death and the "sole" have no birth or death. The main argument is that the soul is eternal and true; it has no birth or death." Marxism's position is that material life is truth. The mind is the part of the brain of a conscious person that stores knowledge. Once things are "in the mind," the "mind" stores that knowledge securely. But in the case of a disease that affects the mind (mental illness); "Alzheimer's", the "mind" does not function in an unconscious state. If brain death occurs due to any reason, the "mind" also dies. But according to spiritual arguments, the "mind" is the "soul". All religions hold the position that "the soul has no death". The argument that "everything is God's will" is a ploy to cover up the poverty that has been part of the economic irregularities in society since the monarchy, and the cruelty shown to them. The spiritualist ideology that "everything is God's destiny" perpetuates the ignorance and poverty of the poor. Spiritualists are ever vigilant to prevent education from reaching the poor. That is the reason for the tactics to eliminate public schools as much as possible.

//

Only if SOCIALISM is accepted as Party Program can its social justice be brought to over one hundred and forty crore Indian people. But those in the CPI(M) Politburo don't know whether there are any such thing as "social justice" in Marxism or socialism. None of them have ever heard of such a things. Because for the past 75 years, since 1950, they have only heard justifications for capitalism. All they know is armed revolution and the dictatorship of the working class. It cannot be told to anyone. They are unaware of the changes that have occurred throughout the world since the time of Karl Marx in the 19th century. They have not known that monarchies have disappeared and democracy has been implemented all over the world. Therefore, let the Indian National Congress or the BJP should rule in India. They will not allow CPIM to contest in Elections in all over India for SOCIALISM. That is the conclusion of the 24th Party Congress of the CPI(M). Communism and Marxism in name only. Socialism and Marxism -- the situation in India and the world during the 1950s was one where ideas "became material power". That was the perception in society that public sectors were the temples of the nation. The "promotion of capitalism" was the reason for eliminating all that.

//

The basis of Marxism is humanity. Even those who work have the right to live with dignity. That is the basic message of Marxism. Ninety percent of society is affected by it. Only ten percent of the wealthy are opposed to it. They own ninety percent of the country's wealth. Those are the social justices of Marxism and socialism. The vast majority of people are humane. They will only vote for socialism. But the Communist parties in India will never give the people a chance to do that. That is the main problem.

//

Those who eat rice food will understand the position that "only the Indian National Congress can save India means declining "Marxism" in total. But Prakash Karat, Vrinda Karat; Manik Sarkar, Suryakant Mishra and others don't understand anything because they eat wheat food. They haven't even heard of Marxism. They will decide everything in the future as well. Because EMS had said that there is no question of socialism implementing through the "parliamentary way". They can firm stand in the words EMS, for ever without caring what anyone else says. Once Dange had suspended AKG for six months for criticizing the Congress. But Sitaram Yechury went much further than Dange. Now the CPI(M) is moving forward only on the words of Yechury. It has no idea what the Congress is and want only capitalism for ever.

//

CPI(M) leaders do not understand that Kerala is a part of India. They are trying to save "Kerala" alone and leave the rest to their own devices. That is the meaning of their firm stand that they will not accept the party program of "Socialist India". Handing over the entire country "INDIA" to Corporates is part of the free growth of capitalist society. It doesn't even take into account that the CPI(M) is an "Indian" party. The Sangh Parivar will not allow meaningless "party congresses" to continue. They will be put in JAIL without trial or shot dead and then declared dead in the courtyards. Until then, there will be no Harihara Kurup.

//19 09 2025//