334. CRITICISM ON CPI(M) PARTY PROGRAMME.
//
As long as CPI (M) continuing in the present Party Program, agitations will not be against Indian Bourgeois;
and those will be against Indian working class and poor peoples, because they are the victims of capitalism. The increase in the price of petroleum products affects the common people and working class as well. The demand that the petroleum sector should only in the public sector will not be accepted as a demand of the CPI(M) struggles in the present situation. It will not be a demand that the Indian Railways should not be privatized and the vacancies in the railways should be filled is the position that capitalism should be promoted. Whatever it may be, no one will notice anything what the suggestions of anybody. It is quite impossible to convince Com. Pinarayi Vijayan; Manik Sarkkar; Biman Basu; Surya kanth Mishra etc. that without the proper help of Central Government, any of the Indian States cannot be in a developed stage and the target of the Party should be the ruling of India. To get such a target, certainly the present stand should be changed and a new Party Program with the target of SOCIALIST INDIA should be admitted and then only party have a target to be achieved and COMMUNIST MOVEMENT IN MARXIAN IDEOLOGY. Then all agitations will be under the concept of CLASS STRUGGLE.
//
The struggles which are carried out without admitting the Party Program of SOCIALIST INDIA will be conducted not against anyone and not for anyone. The results of the struggles of the past are that it does not yield any results. There is the aim of FREE DEVELOPMENT OF CAPITALISM. The struggles never be CLASS STRUGGLES. The basic stand is that it is impossible to demand that "PUBLIC SECTOR INDUSTRIES SHOULD BE PROTECTED". All the wealth of the country should be held by the big CORPORATES. THE POLIT BUREAU AND CENTRAL COMMITTEE OF CPI(M) do not understand that India is actually ruled by CORPORATES and the actual meaning of CAPITAL-ISM. The position is that there are no class enemies there. Things are moving towards the fact that the PARTY PROGRAM will not change. If there is the minimum concept to change the Party Program, the agitations will be to protect Public Properties, because those are the asset of the country and the people as a whole.
//
When I heard in a Party Class in 2002; that the concept of the party is that "INDIAN CAPITALISM" ought to be promoted, I wondered how a "COMMUNIST PARTY" can promote capitalism, and how the ideology can work; but after 22 years, now, the whole party vanished what was in 2002 in over all India. But even now, CPIM PB only planning to COMMIT SUICIDE from Indian politics by trying to strengthening "Indian National Congress"; even though the politics of INC also for "Ram Raj", and they want ZERO SOCIALIST IDEOLOGY AND ZERO COMMUNIST PARTY IN INDIA.
//
It is a fact that I am submitting these matters since 2002; through 22 letters to Com.Harkishan Singh Surjith, S.Ramachandran Pillai; Pinarai Vijayan; etc. as "promoting capitalism" cannot be implemented while "MARXISM" as basic theory of a COMMUNIST PARTY, but nothing had happened except the "PARTY" as a whole vanishing from Indian Politics. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO PRESENT THE ENTIRE MATTER IN ANY PARTY CONFERENCE IN 5 -- 6 MINUTES, AND PARTY WILL NOT PERMIT TO PRESENT IN ANY OTHER WAY. WHILE PROMOTING CAPITALISM; THE SURPLUS VALUE THEORY; CLASS STRUGGLE THEORY AND MATERIALISM AND DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM WILL NOT WORK; AS THESE THEORIES ARE ONLY TO DEMOLISH CAPITALISM AND ONLY TO ESTABLISH SOCIALIST SOCIETY. MARXISM IS NOT A THEORY TO "CORRECT" BOURGEOIS; BUT ONLY TO THROW AWAY THEM FROM POWER. "CLASS CONTRADICTIONS WILL NOT WORK; AS LONG AS PROMOTING BOURGEOIS CONTINUES. The theory of SURPLUS VALUE, work only when admitting SOCIALIST SOCIETY, and the relevance cannot be said in 5 minutes in an ordinary conference of party. And the relevance of other theories also requires more time. And at the time of "PARTY CONGRESSES" since 2002, I had placed before the Central Committees to review the "PARTY PROGRAMME", but nothing happened so far.
//
It is also said that Marxism is accepted by encouraging its enemies. "Marxism" is not to be accepted in words; it should be in action. When agreeing to loot the PSUs; don't fool the people by declaring that the working class has no enemies; no one can admit Marxism. If any one have convinced that it is wrong, it should correct. The lesson of history is that the CPI(M) Polit Bureau will not do that. The position is that the "PARTY PROGRAM" is not ready to be revised.
//
The danger of adopting the position of promoting capitalism is that the whole party came to the position that the Communist Movement and SOCIALISM have no enemies. The whole party leadership felt that there are no necessity of socialism. That is enough if the BJP is removed from the power; in the last 23rd Party Congress, it was agreed that India should be ruled by the Indian National Congress. But what about class enemies? From K Sudhakaran, KPCC President in Kerala to Donald Trump in the United States, the anti-communists are fighting with all their skills, wealth and beliefs, and the party leadership did not take into account the fact that there should be no red flag or socialist ideology should see anywhere in the world.
//
The basis of the class struggle is the conflict between slave and master, the conflict between worker and employer, and the clash of contradictions. In India, when it was decided to promote the owner or the boss (promoting capitalism), the situation came to the point where class conflicts would not move towards class struggle. This is the reason for the stagnation of the movement in India since 1950. This situation will change only when the target of a socialist social system; free from exploitation is accepted.. Actually CLASS STRUGGLE is between SOCIALISM Vs CAPITALISM. While USSR was a fact, all imperialist forces were tried hard to demolish SOCIALISM from the world.
CLASS STRUGGLE IS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT WEAPON OF MARXISM TO FIGHT AGAINST BOURGEOIS; AND ACCORDING TO LENIN; (WHAT IS TO BE DONE?) STRIKES OF WORKING CLASS IN CAPITALISM SHOULD BE WITH A VIEW TO MAKE A SENSE OF CLASS UNITY; AND WHICH SHOULD LEAD TO CLASS STRUGGLE AND THAT SHOULD END ONLY IN DEMOLISHING CAPITALISM AND SUPREMACY OF BOURGEOIS. AS LONG AS THE PRESENT PROGRAMME IS GOING ON; IT IS IMPOSSIBLE.
/
"KARL MARX IS RIGHT".
//
Karl Marx specified when starting his formation of MARXISM is that only economic base structure will decide its political and cultural super structure. (A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy; Book by Karl Marx) IT MEANS IN CAPITALISM; ONLY BOURGEOIS WILL DECIDE WHO MUST BE THEIR RULERS AND THEY WILL NOT ADMIT A COMMUNIST PARTY TO RULE THEM AND TO DECIDE THEIR DEALINGS. THE EXPERIENCE SINCE 1950s IN INDIA; WE CAN ADMIT THIS AND THE GROWTH OF THE COMMUNIST MOVEMENT ALSO PROVE IT. With the concept to promote CAPITALISM; IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO ESTABLISH PEOPLES DEMOCRACY IN CAPITALISM. If socialism is to be implemented, it is the working class that has to enjoy the results and become the foundation. It is the responsibility of the working class to implement it. But, unfortunately, when decided to promote the existing bourgeois class structure; actual working class became victims and bourgeois will act deadly against MARXISM and COMMUNIST MOVEMENT and that is happening since 1950s.
//
It is a fact that only according to the situations prevailing in each country, any organization can function including Communist parties. Before 1947, the political sovereignty of India were vested in British queen, and after Independence, and after admitting "democracy" each citizen has political empowerment also. These facts were ignored the leaders of the Communist movement during 1950s. The political situation of India basically changed after Independence from British Imperialism when getting its Independence in August 15,1947. When neglecting the actual target of SOCIALISM; basic target of MARXISM, an exploitation free social system, after demolishing the existing exploitative class structure and deciding to promote capitalism and strengthen bourgeois, the ideology MARXISM became out of field. Lenin specifically saying in his almost all books that "ONLY ECONOMIC BASE STRUCTURE OF THE COUNTRY WILL DECIDE ITS POLITICAL AND CULTURAL UPPER STRUCTURE". In India; nobody could understood it; even Com EMS. So implementing the program is impossible; according to Karl Marx with the concept to promote the Feudal and 4 caste system with the supremacy of BRAHMANISM". And also the Class struggle theory, the basic stand that "CLASS CONTRADICTIONS" were became field out when making collaboration with bourgeois, the ancient slave owner, and the present bourgeois or capitalist. I am not fixing its responsibility on anybody because ignorance or failure to understand the class contradictions cannot be placed as guilty. And also, the complications of political empowerment when changing from MONARCHY TO ORDINARY CITIZEN and the difference of old local "KINGDOM" and the FEDERAL NATURE of a country with very large population.
//
At least one person in CPI and CPI(M) leadership who understands the difference between the situation where the Communist Party had no freedom of action in India before 1950 and the situation where the Indian Constitution was approved "SOCIALISM" by a four-fifths majority in the Indian Parliament, the political atmosphere of India would not have been a Hindutva reign of terror. Because the communist movement in India did not accept the goal of socialism, the people gave the mandate to the Indian National Congress and the fact that the Congress did not implement the mandate does not eliminate the mandate for socialism of the vast majority of the Indian people. Communist movements in India must take up and carry out the political duty of carrying out the mandate of the people for socialism. The fact that everything is always subject to change also requires democratic changes in the commodity production system in the socialist system from the old Soviet Union. According to that, Socialist China is moving forward. The Communist movement in India should be able to move forward according to the Indian people's decision in the event that the Indian Constitution itself has accepted the socialist system.
//
Full implementation of the Indian Constitution is essential if the tribute to the great Dr. BR Ambedkar, the original architect of the Indian Constitution, is to be completed. Its fundamental basis is the equality of Indian citizens enshrined in Article 14. All are human; Article 14 of the Constitution also reflects that humanity should be the basic quality that everyone should have. Marxism is the only philosophy that treats all as human beings; it also has its real roots in Buddhism. The essence of Marxism is that working people also have the right to live in dignity. The interest of the bourgeois politician or the exploiting class is that will not allow under any circumstances. They are one in the world in that regard. Poor people who do not understand their scams also become victims of their scams and end up making their own lives miserable. To bourgeois politician, "God" is just a mask. Buddhism was based on a scientific outlook and compassion for all living beings. That was the reason why the great Dr. Ambedkar accepted Buddhism.
Brahmanism eliminated Buddhism in India because it did not recognize Brahmanical "greatness" and Aswamedha, etc. "sacrifices". Buddhist monasteries were burned down and Buddhist monks were killed. But it still exists in countries like China, Japan, Sri Lanka etc. Buddhism was the religion adopted by Emperor Ashoka. If "Ashoka Pillar" is our national symbol, the religion that should stand in India is Buddhism. Buddhism does not accept the Chaturvarnya system. The Buddhist position is that no living being can come from anyone's face, chest, etc.
//
"MARXISM" only for SOCIALISM. WITHOUT ADMITTING
"SOCIALIST INDIA" AS "PARTY PROGRAM", IDEOLOGY WILL NOT BE IN FIELD, PARTY WILL NOT EXIST, CANNOT DEFEND HINDU FUNDAMENTALISTS, KINDLY CONVINCE REALITY.
//
It was heard as the decision of the 23rd CPI(M) Party Congress reported that "the party had nowhere said that socialism can be established by "bourgeois parliamentary means". This means that the party does not accept democracy and Indian Constitution which admitting SOCIALISM also with 4/5 majority of Indian citizens. Even though it was behind Indian National Congress were happened to such changes in Indian Constitution; it also expressing the decision of Indian people as a whole. If the Communist movements moving forward with the Constitution contents, wholehearted co-operation of Indian peoples will also with the Communist Party with getting peoples mandate. Please see the the question of armed revolution was relevant only in a monarchy, is now out of question of humanity as in a democracy where every citizen enjoys political freedom and humanity cannot go to history.
//
We cannot establish "SOCIALISM" through armed revolution because socialism is a stage of the society where the needs of the peoples meet through economic development through socialist planning and wholehearted co-operation of working class through so many years. Agriculture, Medical treatment and Education etc. should not be considered on "PROFIT" motivated field and only in SOCIALISM, the "GOVERNMENT" can handle in feasible and suitable to meet the citizens in amenity. Providing houses to everybody (those who actually requires) should be considered as a liability of the Government. Certainly it requires so many years. Political freedom in democracy enables the worker to use his vote to escape from the exploitative politics of bourgeois. Parliament and legislative assemblies are essential in socialism also for law making and the rule of law. In democracy, there are freedom of opinion/media, which facilitate to convince the people about the justice of MARXISM and SOCIALISM, which were impossible during MONARCHY, but now citizens have freedom to elect anybody to rule them. During the period of MONARCHY, it was impossible. In a socialist society, working class are not working for merely wages; but also to set up a society where exploitation will not occur; and also their all kinds of amenities will be attended by the socialist society. In capitalism it is impossible.Kindly CPI (M) Central Committee may consider to change the Party Programme, by admitting SOCIALIST INDIA, THROUGH PEOPLES DEMOCRACY, UNLESS THE RULING OF BJP/HINDUTHWA will continue for ever and also it will lead to zero COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS IN INDIA.
//
CPI(M) PARTY PROGRAM IS NOT FORMED CONSIDERING THE FEDERAL SYSTEM OF INDIAN CONSTITUTION WHICH IS CONSIDERING INDIA AS A WHOLE AND SUPREME AUTHORITY AS "INDIAN PARLIAMENT" AND CENTRAL GOVERNMENT. SO EACH AND EVERY ACTION OF PARTY BASED ON "STATE LEVEL" AS "SINGLE UNIT" with power to decide coalition with any bourgeois parties. It is actually wonder that a COMMUNIST PARTY considering that it have no responsibilities to anything of the COUNTRY AND PEOPLES and how can to solve any problems. It is only due to ignorance of the FEDERAL NATURE of the country, and it thinks that if getting the ruling of any "STATE", will do "something" without any commitments to anybody. WITHOUT MAJOR INCOME, MAJOR INDUSTRIES AND WITH VERY LIMITED POWERS, A STATE GOVERNMENT CANNOT BECOME A DEVELOPED STAGE. That was caused the drawbacks in Bengal, even though ruled 34 years continuously.
//
The most important defect of the "PARTY PROGRAM" is that the PROGRAM is not considering the federal nature of Indian Constitution. According to the Constitution, the political power vested in Indian Parliament and Central Government. The Central Government can decide what should do the "STATE GOVERNMENTS". Due to the ignorance of this fact, when getting chance to rule any Indian States, the leaders are considering that they can do everything to the people, but when "CENTRAL GOVERNMENT" preventing each and every actions of State Government, leaders of the "STATE" became helpless. As a party representing the whole of the country, the Party Program should be with the target of the country as a whole.
//
AS LONG AS THE PRESENT PROGRAMME CONTINUING; THERE ARE NO TARGET TO BE ACHIEVED; BECAUSE "CAPITALISM" WILL NEVER BECOME A TARGET OF A COMMUNIST PARTY. DEVELOPED STAGE OF CAPITALISM IS ONLY "IMPERIALISM". (REFER THE BOOK OF LENIN; IMPERIALISM IS THE HIGHEST FORM OF CAPITALISM)
//
AS PER PARA 6.5 OF CPI (M) PARTY PROGRAMME; ECONOMIC POLICY IS "MULTI PHASED, WITH VARIOUS FORMS OF OWNERSHIP" IS ONLY "MIXED ECONOMY" OF INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS, AND THEY ARE ALSO WITH CAPITALISM; CPIM BENGAL COMRADES AND G S YECHURI ARE FIRM WITH COALITION WITH INC BECAUSE OF SAME AND ONE ECONOMIC POLICY IGNORING THE HISTORY OF DANGE AND CPI. WITHOUT CHANGING PARTY PROGRAMME; NOBODY CAN CORRECT THOSE COMRADES NEGLECTING MARXISM AND CLASS STRUGGLE THEORY.
//
SOCIALISM IS POSSIBLE IN A SOVEREIGN COUNTRY. IN INDIA, THE SUPREME POLITICAL POWERS VESTED IN INDIAN PARLIAMENT AND GOVERNMENT OF INDIA. MAJOR INCOME SUCH AS INCOME TAX, EXCISE TAX, CUSTOMS DUTY; ETC. WILL BE VESTED IN CENTRAL GOVERNMENT AND CENTRAL GOVERNMENT WILL ALLOW SOME PORTIONS OF IT TO STATE GOVERNMENTS. AT PRESENT; CPI (M) PARTY PROGRAMME IS NOT CONSIDERING SUCH MATTERS.
//
CLASS STRUGGLE IS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT WEAPON OF MARXISM TO FIGHT AGAINST BOURGEOIS; AND ACCORDING TO LENIN; (WHAT IS TO BE DONE?) STRIKES OF WORKING CLASS IN CAPITALISM SHOULD BE WITH A VIEW TO MAKE A SENSE OF CLASS UNITY; AND WHICH SHOULD LEAD TO CLASS STRUGGLE AND THAT SHOULD END ONLY IN DEMOLISHING CAPITALISM AND SUPREMACY OF BOURGEOIS. AS LONG AS THE PRESENT PROGRAMME IS GOING ON; IT IS IMPOSSIBLE.
//
Nobody can protect farmers in capitalism as bourgeois are keen to suck the blood of farmers and workers. Please see the historic struggle of farmers during 2020-21, in which about 1000 farmers committed suicide, but nothing happened through the strike, and the farmers also in struggle. No one can save the peasant except under SOCIALISM. Please see the stage of farmers in China, where Government fixing the price of farm products and also rendering all facilities to market the farm products through Railway. In capitalism, where maximum profit of capitalists and the remedy of the farmer is suicide. In today's situation, even the goal of socialism cannot be pointed out in front of the farmer. The plight of farmers all over India and the plight of rubber farmers and related workers in Kerala is such that a solution cannot even be suggested as long as the present program continues. Only if the agricultural produce gets a fair price can the agricultural laborer get a living wage. While the farmer gets Rs.1 per kg of onion; anyone can imagine the plight of the agricultural laborer when the farmer commits suicide. If socialism is the goal then these things can be presented to the people in the elections. The current struggles are not yielding any results. If the country is in the way of SOCIALIST path, India also adopt the way of China, where the price of farm products are decided by the "GOVERNMENT" and the farm labors get adequate minimum wage as fixing by the Government and also everybody providing houses, education, medical treatment, life protection etc. are the responsibility of the Government.
//
According to the CPI (M) PARTY PROGRAMME; 6.2 it is only possible by replacing the BOURGEOIS - LANDLORD to establish PEOPLES DEMOCRACY. While deciding to promote CAPITALISM it is possible only BY PROMOTING BOURGEOIS-LANDLORDS BECAUSE THEY ARE INDUSTRIALISTS. ANYBODY CAN PROMOTE MUKESH AMBANI; ADANI ETC. IN ANY WAY. BUT AT THE SAME TIME THEY SHOULD BE REPLACED to establish "PEOPLES DEMOCRACY". HOW IT WILL BECOME PRACTICABLE? Please convince its impracticability since 1950s; for the last 70 years in India and the result thereafter since 1950s.
//
"MAN POWER EXPLOITATION" IS ONLY ONE SIDE OF A COIN OF CAPITALIST EXPLOITATION AND THE OTHER SIDE IS "SOUL" (ATMEEYA)" BY WAY OF CASTE/RELIGION/GOD AND "HINDUTHWA" IS ONLY A NATIONAL HIGHWAY OF IT.
To conceal the process of exploitation from working class; Bourgeois will convince working class and poor peoples through priests (BRAHMINS & OTHERS) that their life in the earth is not actual life, everything are deciding by God; actual life begins only after their death and for securing a better position in heaven, all are based on their fate; they should pray to the God, otherwise they will be placed in hell by God. This is only cheating the poor peoples and to continue the exploitation there were continuing for thousands of years. By applying "FOUR CASTE SYSTEM", according to "HINDU" ideology; there are no human beings; only some castes.
Actually everything are creating by working class of all castes and religions. We can see that every "products" those humanity consuming are the out come of working class and nobody can split it on the base of caste or religion. Actually "God" is only an idea of somebody. In all parts of the world; there are no unanimity for god; in each parts of the world; God had different name and shape.
(To defend this is only by applying MATERIALISM AND DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM means there should be "SCIENTIFIC VIEW" of social issues. But when promoting capitalism, it is impossible).
//
ACCORDING TO MARXIAN ECONOMY AND SURPLUS VALUE THEORY...at least one hour of work; out of eight hours; will get the bourgeois in one day's work as wage less man power otherwise he will not engage any worker in his firm.
THIS, WE CAN CALCULATE, OUT OF 140 CR. INDIAN CITIZENS; AT LEAST (MINIMUM) 50 CRORES OF MAN POWER WILL GET INDIAN BOURGEOIS (CAPITALISM) PER DAY; AND THIS IS ACTUAL EXPLOITATION ON MAN POWER AND THIS IS ACTUAL BASE OF CAPITALISM AND WHEN DECIDING TO ESTABLISH A SOCIALIST SOCIETY; THIS WILL BE DEMOLISHED BECAUSE THIS IS THE BASE OF SOCIALIST ECONOMY AND WITHOUT TAKEN A DECISION TO STOP EXPLOITATION; WE CANNOT BUILT UP A SOCIALIST SOCIETY. WHEN PROMOTING CAPITALISM; IGNORING CLASS STRUGGLE THEORY, PROMOTING EXPLOITATION; NO MARXISM WILL FUNCTION.
//
As long as "PROMOTING CAPITALISM" is following, "POLITICAL TACTICS" will be always against WORKING CLASS AND POOR PEOPLES, because its after effects are PETROLEUM PRICE HIKES, price hikes all commodities, poverty, unemployment, communal clashes and all hardships those poor peoples suffering and also they will always against us. . Its remedy is only SOCIALISM. And also MARXISM is only against capitalism and its exploitation.
//
So CPI(M) and LEFT DEMOCRATIC FORCES OF INDIA asking the peoples verdict to become INDIA to be a SOCIALIST COUNTRY only as per the CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, as according to the CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, India is a SOVEREIGN, SOCIALIST, SECULAR, DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC.
.//03 04 2020//
