574. IF THERE ARE NO "LEFT", THERE WILL BE NO "INDIA".
"MARXISM" is the philosophy of kindness and humanity. Those only goodness in mind can become a COMMUNIST. So even though a brahmin and land lord, EMS of KERALA, became a COMMUNIST LEADER OF INDIA.
//
Without the target of "SOCIALIST INDIA", there are no validity for "LEFT" IDEOLOGY.
/
The bourgeois political parties like Indian National Congress, "HINDUTHWA" based BJP etc. considering that "POWER" should be only for lavish life and making money through scam and corruption. How "the people living" will not be their port folio in any way. The position of the bourgeois politicians is that if they get votes by making fools of the people in the elections, they can do anything until the next elections. But even that will not be possible for a long time, as is evident from the failure of the Indian National Congress in most of the North Indian states. Hindutva Vadis are also following the same path. Leftist political parties should take the position of winning people's approval for socialist India as recognized by the Constitution of India. Neither Karl Marx nor Engels defined any model for socialism to be implemented in all countries. Marx's aim in life was to eliminate the poverty of working people. The Indian Constitution also does not define the model of socialism to be implemented.
//
If the target is "SOCIALISM", it is not a problem for Marxism to face the political movements of the Indian exploiters in India, the Indian National Congress and the Hindutvas called the BJP.
//
"SOCIALISM" IS THE LAW OF NATURE".
Each and every human beings are only "one" among living things of "NATURE". Human beings are also under the strict laws of "nature". "NATURE" have decided every things such as what should be its life period, its food, living circumstances, method of reproduction and human beings also liable to obey the decisions of nature. The common factors available in nature such as Earth, Sun light, water, oxygen, etc. are intended to every living things including human beings. Unfortunately, only a lot of human beings denying their mere living situation due to black laws and hooliganism of some anti socials. Anybody denying to human beings what "nature" provided is only "ANTI NATURE". We can consider the "NATURE" as "GOD" which actually decided everything; but nature doesn't want "pray" of anybody like the human created artificial gods. What is available in nature are entitled to enjoy human beings also like all other living things. In "EARTH" about 73% are "SEA" and there are crores of living things and every things have plenty of every things actually they want and there are no Government; Police; Communal riots or anythings to prevent the freedom of anything. Even if one acquires all the wealth in the world through anti-social activities, no one can increase his total life span or use the acquired wealth.
//
That India would be a "SOCIALIST STATE" was accepted by the Indian people with a four-fifths majority in Parliament and became part of the Indian Constitution itself. Just because the people of India voted for the Indian National Congress and the Congress did not implemented it, the interests of the people cannot be ruled out. The people of India are still living in India. The Left movements have to get popular verdict to realize the political goal of Socialist India.
//
It is a fact that when it is said, "If there is no "LEFT", there will be no India", not everyone will convince it because for them India is just a map of India. But the post-independence India that has come into being is a "Secular India" of all religious denominations with a vision of "unity in diversity" and the sovereignty envisioned in the CONSTITUTION; Socialist; Democratic; Secular; "India" will survive or not. Following "RAM RAJ" means only declining everything. Therein lies the danger of the Indian National Congress's stance of aiming for the "Ram Kingdom" envisioned by the Bharatiya Janata Party. One can see on any issue that the Indian National Congress is not prepared to oppose any stand of violent communalism by the Hindu communalists. The fact is that the Indian National Congress sees the present Indian Constitution as a real "sovereign; socialist; secular; democratic republic" as a burden. The stance of INC is that the cause of their loss of power since 2014 was due to loss of "HINDUTHWA FACE" and they also want get back the support of rigid "HINDUTHWA". It means only INC also gave up their face of "SECULAR" and economic policy based on mixed economy and socialist concept. The actual fact is that the present leadership of INC have gave up entire past history of Congress with mixed economy and anti corruption policy including secularism.
Indian National Congress always giving top priority only against ANTI LEFT POLITICS means ANTI SOCIALIST concepts. They want ZERO RED FLAG IN INDIA and only exist either INC or BJP. Even protection of Indian Constitution only below priory than LEFT politics. It only means that INC also becoming another face of BJP. That is where everyone is human; those who want humanity to exist arrive at the view that "there is no India without the Left" which recognizes that "humanity" is a quality that should be present in all. Those who want India to remain as it is will be saddened when any Congress leader will go to the BJP camp and no one sees any danger in doing so. It should also be noted that almost anyone in the Indian National Congress fully agrees with all the anti-social stances of the Hindu communalists.
//
The Communist parties of India have taken the position of relying on the Indian National Congress to end the reign of terror of the Hindutva in India in the general elections of 2019 and 2024. But the Congress is for "Rama Raj" and is totally agree with all the economic measures, corruption and anti-socialist stance of the Hindutvaists. Moreover, they are of the position that the Communist Party should be completely abolished in India. In order to avoid the split of votes against the BJP, despite the fact that the Communist parties stayed out of the contest as much as possible, the position taken by the Congress was to defeat the left-wing candidates wherever they contested. Nobody can expect any changes in the stance of the Congress in the future also. Only those who accept Marxism can implement the Indian Constitution formed under the leadership of BR Ambedkar in its full meaning and eliminate the Hindutva terror regime.
//
If there are not the target of SOCIALISM" , there will not be the ideology of MARXISM can work. So, if there are not the target of SOCIALISM, there will not be the political movement of "LEFT" can exist. I have doubt whether the COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS in India had been convinced it even though COMMUNIST MOVEMENT working in India for the last one CENTURY, because since 1950s, for the last 74 years, COMMUNIST MOVEMENT working only for the rapid development of BOURGEOIS AND CAPITALISM, even though the great Karl Marx introduced the ideology only for SOCIALIST SOCIETY, to get rid of exploitation , the working class experiencing all over the world.A hundred years after its inception, in a country with a population of one hundred and forty crores; in the 28-state country, only Kerala has seen significant competition in the 2024 Parliament Election. In the remaining 27 states, the stance taken was to strengthen the Indian exploiting classes; bourgeois to promote capitalism.It is in no way compatible with the philosophy of Marxism. Strengthen the Indian National Congress, which has a firm stand that red flag politics should not exist in India for any reason; Acting with the intention of handing over the rule of India is only an anti-Marxist position, a declaration of disapproval of Marxism.
//
It is a fact that nobody will vote for CAPITALISM if it is narrated actually what is CAPITALISM even to bourgeois political parties including INC AND BJP, because it is only "MASK" to hide the ill-motivated intentions of bourgeois; but they are giving it the name "democracy" (bourgeois).
//
BE AN ACTUAL MARXIST, THAT WILL ENABLE YOU TO BECOME INNOCENT, STERN, INTELLGENT, CLEVER, KINDNESS TO EVERYBODY, TO FIND OUT EXACT FACT, ALWAYS WITH ACTUAL WORKING CLASS AS THEY ARE BEHIND ACTUAL WEALTH OF THE WORLD. BEHIND KARL MARX, ALL GOOD PERSONALTIES AND THEIR GOODNESS WILL STILL ALIVE.
//
Marxism is a philosophy of humanity. The position of Marxism is that everybody should live in mutual cooperation with the awareness that everyone is human. It is necessary for the existence of all religious believers. All human beings need sense of science. In the religious texts we can see the scientific knowledge of the time when they came into being. The horrors of Hindu communalism are felt by those who believe in other religions in India are not human beings. The experience of countries where there are more people belonging to one religion means that people belonging to other religions are not bad at all. The terror that is happening in Israel also shows the lack of awareness that everyone is human. Women are denied human rights in Afghanistan. The position there is that higher education should not be for women. The reason for that is the anti-science of the religion there. They are denying the natural law or God's determination that man and woman are necessary for the existence of living things. Believers of all religions must be prepared to accommodate the changes that come with the times. Otherwise the mutual killings will continue. The aim of those who create communal separation is exploitative class strategy to divide and exploit the people. This is a matter of interest to both Hindutva (BJP) and Indian National Congress. The basic goal is that no one should be "human."
//
During the days when the world was afraid of the epidemic of "Covid 19", not a single person died in Kerala only a State in India due to lack of breathing air. In the 2018 flood in Kerala, the houses of lakhs of people in the Kuttanad area of Alappuzha district were washed away by mud and human waste and the wells and septic tanks were destroyed. The service rendered by more than fifty thousand peoples those (believing in Marxism-accepting movements) who reached there and cleaned without expecting anything. Nobody had arrived there for the help of those affected flood sufferings as such work need patience and lot of obstacles as travel facility, food availability, etc. Young people delivering food to patients and their companions who reaching at MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITALS, which are shelters for the most economically back. All are characteristic of the humanity of the philosophy of "Marxism". No one should ever expect such qualities from other organizations those who motivated only under selfishness.
//
The peculiarities of the philosophy of "Marxism" is that those who understand it, accept it, are honest in their lives and the subjects they dealt with, and show absolute sincerity. Those who keep in mind all the selfishness and ugliness of capitalism will not understand it. Com. EMS was a landlord and a Brahmin which did not affected his activities as a Communist Leader, who was the first Chief Minister of Kerala. No one needs to be introduced about him in India. It is the same in the All India Undivided Communist Party and later in the CPI and CPI(M) no one is tainted in personal life. In terms of sincerity, those who succeed in whatever task is assigned to them are the ones who succeed to the best of their ability. It is the peculiarity of the philosophy of Marxism that they believe in. Once Com. Pinarayi Vijayan said to press representatives at a press conference: "You don't know any thing about our party". That comrade only stated a fact. But the press representatives did not understand anything. The change in those who understand the philosophy of "Marxism" cannot be understood by those who do not. That is the specialty of Marxism. The life of laborers who work and have to suffer hardship and poverty all their lives is honest. Compassion for their lives led the great Karl Marx to formulate the philosophy of "Marxism". Because of that, those who believe in that philosophy will be honest and do justice to Karl Marx's life target.
//
Since the 1950s, the Communist movements in India has not admitted the target (party program) of establishing socialism in India. Perhaps it may be occurred due to the inability to grasp the contradiction between the interest of slave and the slave owner. But promoting capitalism means only promoting the slave owner and deadly against the interest of slave and modern working class. The then undivided Communist Party and after the split in 1964 CPI and CPI(M) were the view that Indian capitalism should grow; Both the CPI and CPI(M) parties have accepted it. So what happens according to ideology, is that it does not accept that it is exploitative class rule that exists. Then there will be no class enemies. It means that there are no "exploitation" and no need the ideology of MARXISM as it was only introduced to protect WORKING CLASS from exploitation. Karl Marx wrote the great work "Capital" to establish how the worker, working class as a whole is subjected to exploitation. The content of the work "DAS CAPITAL" totally declined in India since 1950s. If you want to enter into an alliance with the Indian National Congress, do not admit that they are a political movement of class enemies. Abandoned in India are Marx's findings that "the entire written history of mankind is the history of class struggles." But what about the Indian National Congress? When the Communist Party came to power in Kerala in 1957, a liberation movement was launched against it and that government was dissolved using the Central Government. And that red flag politics should not exist in India under any circumstances; And that the Indian working class should not, for any reason, be freed from the extreme hunger and perpetual poverty they suffer. The position of the Congress is that it should always remain in the grip of Brahminism and the hell under four--caste system. The Indian National Congress had undoubtedly proved through their 65 years ruling in India that they are only representing Bourgeois and Land Lords and only to prevent the growth of Indian Working Class Movement and socialist ideology in India. The Bharatheeya Janatha Party @ BJP also with the same Politics of Indian National Congress. In India, the Indian National Congress and the Hindutva Bharatiya Janata Party have adopted only part of the position adopted by the World Imperialist powers, including the United States, that there should be no socialist social system anywhere in the world. Even after 1950s, "Party leaders" have decided to continue with the position of 1950 regardless of how miserable the situation of the Communist parties in India has become for 74 years hard work. The reason is that it does not accept that the rule of the exploiting class exists. And there is no need for Marxism. Because Karl Marx formulated the philosophy of "Marxism" only for a non-exploitative social system. Neither Lenin, who founded the Soviet Union, nor Mao Zedong, China, seemed to turn to the idea of promoting capitalism.
//
The election to Indian Parliament held on 26 4 2024 from Kerala was unique from other states in India is that Kerala with a "left-wing Government". It is also important to note that the "humanity" of the philosophy of Marxism has at work. "Humanity" is only a quality of Marxism. It does not come down to basic principles. Basic principles means accepting the fact that exploitative class rule exists. Karl Marx's economics is about saving the people who take jobs and are exploited by the rich classes, including the working class, from being exploited by the rich classes. The theory of class struggle is to end the economic dominance of the exploiting classes. "Materialism and Contradictory Materialism" is a scientific social perspective. The aim of Marxism is to bring mankind to a socialist system. For that, the class rule of the exploiting classes must be ended. The Communist movement in India has been promoted Indian capitalism for 74 years since the 1950s on the basis of "free growth of Indian capitalism" which does not accept any of the ideology MARXISM. So I have been trying for many years to convince the communist leaders in India that the philosophy of "Marxism" cannot work, but the communist leaders are not convinced. With the exception of Kerala, India faced elections with a stance of strengthening the Indian exploiting classes and entrusting them with the ruling of the future India. Therefore, except in Kerala, even the humanitarian aspect of "Marxism" does not come into action. No matter how many times it was said that there is no effect of Marxism to face the political movements of the Indian exploiters like the Indian National Congress and the Hindutva BJP in India. But if the goal is socialism, no one will be convinced that defeating INC and BJP is not a heavy task.
As the communist parties all over India stand firmly on the stand of the free growth of capitalism, they gave full support to the big capitalists to subjugate the entire national wealth that the country has accumulated for a long time after Independence. The party leadership has taken a surprising stand on the issue of handing over the entire public sector wealth to Corporates. The party leadership did not understand that they were built by the sweat of the working class and that the wealth of the country is the wealth of the people. Due to total ban on recruitment, employment opportunities will be completely eliminated and thus the benefits of reservation for the backward classes will not be an issue in the election. The most important thing in Kerala was to overturn the Constitution and make religion the basis of citizenship. Of course it is very important. But it did not consider that elections are opportunities to make common people aware of politics. No one even takes into account that capitalism never has a "maximum growth" phase because science changes so quickly. The fact that old Russia and China were completely backward countries with regard to industrial growth were also did not prevent them from advancing on the path of socialism.
//
If the Communist Movements in India do not take a political decision that India should have a left-wing government with socialist views, in the future elections result also will be the same in 2029; 2034. Because the issue of the people is who should rule India in the Parliamentary Elections. The only way before the people to avoid being ruled by the Hindutva (BJP) is to vote for the Congress. But the results of the 2019 and 2024 elections shows that the Indian people are not ready to hand over the ruling of India to the Indian National Congress, which has ruled India for 65 years and also the Indian National Congress has the same economic policies, such as Hindu Commnalism; killing public sector industries for getting "ELECTORAL BONDS", corruption etc. . To avoid such situations, there should be candidates of the Left Front are contesting in every states in India. The Communist Movement, which has been operating for a hundred years, has the organizational capacity to do so. Lack of confidence; It is only because of lack of knowledge about the philosophy of Marxism.
//
The lack of understanding with the philosophy of Marxism is the only reason why the party program which has been continuing since the 1950s does not see any role in the miserable defeats in Kerala in the elections to the Indian Parliament in 2019 and 2024 and the basic classes became voters of Anti Comnunist sectors. For the free growth of the capitalist society, all the public sector institutions and banks in India were privatized and all the appointments there were completely abolished, but no such facts were placed before the people during the election opportunities, it happened as a full support for the economic positions of the Indian National Congress and the Hindutva activists. Attempts have been made to bring such matters to the attention of the party on several occasions but in vogue. There was no sign of knowing that the employment opportunities of the backward and forward groups would be completely eliminated. The advanced classes are comparatively financially capable. But even the deep pits of perpetual poverty in which the Scheduled Castes and other backward groups, who get fifty percent of the total job opportunities, are falling due to thousands of years of backwardness, did not come to the attention of the party leadership. They too take shelter in the Hindu camp under the delusion that becoming a "Hindu" will remedy their backwardness.
//
Narendra Modi's target is poor nation and poor people. For that, the Constitution of India and democracy are subverted. Public sector industries, banks and natural resources, which are the nation's wealth, are sold to big capitalists because if they are the wealth of the nation, they cannot be corrupted as "Electoral Bonds". The permanent employment of the youth will be eliminated and the vast majority of the population will be in hunger and poverty. That is the ultimate goal of Hindutva. If the country want to be rich, the people must be rich. People are just a handful of big capitalists for Narendra Modi. Ninety-nine percent of people are not "people" to Narendra Modi. The concept of the bourgeois parties like the Indian National Congress and Bharatiya Janata Party etc. is that political activity means to come to power by fooling the people anyway and doing scam; corruption, and oppression of women and poor people. Through the ruling of over 65 years , Indian National Congress had proved actually what was their actual target, which certainly far away from the prosperity of Indian people. But it is the concept of proletarian politics as governed by Marxism to establish that "POLITICS" means doing working for the people especially actual working class. People also testing political parties in elections and when they realizing that actual bourgeois politics is only cheating the people, they will reject them and this is the cause of INC and BJP in India.
//
The political task to be undertaken by the Left movements is to lead the people towards the goal of a socialist India envisioned by the Indian Constitution. Now the leftist government in Kerala is proving that the prosperity of the country means the prosperity of all the working people and politics means working honestly for the country and the people. But in a federal system, when the sovereignty of the country rests with the Parliament and the Central government, no matter how long any one state rules alone, significant changes cannot be made. If India is ruled by the Left, it will not be like a bourgeois politics such as the Congress-BJP, which has wreaked havoc in the country despite having the opportunity to rule the center and the state simultaneously. If there is a majority in the Parliament, the entire land and resources of the country can be used for the entire people. Then there will never be people who sleep on the side of the road without a house to live in and get into a cargo lorry--to get off and surrender to death. All the homeless can be given space, house, free treatment and free education. That is why there should be a leftist government in India. That is why the communist movements in India should appeal to the people for their votes.
/
RULERS SHOULD BE HONEST ALWAYS.
//
Administrators should be honest and socially responsible. If the nation is rich then its benefits will be available to all the people of the country. Hindutva Party (BJP) and Narendra Modi are against all this. Narendra Modi is not honest. Lying is his instinct. BJP's position is that the nation should be poor. The wealth of the country should be entirely owned by a few private individuals. Then the rulers get bribes from them. That is why Narendra Modi and BJP are completely privatizing public sector institutions. Its danger will be the total hardships of the people of the country. These are the common positions of those who accept the capitalist system. That is why it is suggested that the country should be in a socialist system. In a socialist system, the state would determine the entire economic structure of the country. In a democratic system, people can choose such people through elections.
//
The aristocrats and rich people of the old monarchy, who do not understand what democracy really is, will try to take the people back to the monarchy. "Political power", which was reserved only to the king during the monarchy, is vested in each citizen in a democracy. Every citizen has the right to hold his own opinion, to form political parties, to hold any elected post in any office and to nominate anyone. But the reactionary forces who are trying to take the people back to the old days of "monarchy" are trying to eliminate all the democratic rights of the people. Part of it is that Hindutvaists are trying to establish "Rama Rajya" and the Indian National Congress is fully supporting it. They will continue to try to eliminate maximum permanent employment, increase working hours, eliminate labor laws, and establish the absence of political power for the people. Such efforts are bound to be defeated at any cost to preserve the democratic rights. Anti-democratic--thuggish political violence will have to be defeated as a sport. But the fact that the majority of the society are true democracy lovers and all the laws are in favor of the common people helps to sustain the democracy. In India, Hindutva activists and the Indian National Congress are pursuing the same goal as those who made counter-revolutionary coup attempts for four years in old Russia, where the October Revolution took place. But the modern parliamentary democracy which came into being as a result of four years of proletariat struggles for socialism in old Russia is giving strength to the Indian proletariat too.
//
"Humanism" is the most important aspect of the philosophy of "Marxism". Humanity is a part that is not discussed by many people because it is not part of basic philosophy. Comrades will think that there is no need to discuss anything about what happens when socialism is implemented. When the class enemies decide that the philosophy of Marxism should not exist under any circumstances, in order to survive them, the aspect of humanity must be brought to everyone's attention.
//
The basis of Marxism is "humanity". Workers or those who work in various fields are those who maintain the society by sweating their own blood throughout their life. Those who illegally possess the entire wealth of the country are making life hell on earth to them. It has continued since the introduction of the private property system. In earlier times they were called slave owners, but in modern times they are called "capitalists". Slaves then are still largely slaves today. Lenin gave them the name "Wage Slaves". In the olden days owners were responsible for the protection of slaves. their place to sleep; food; care up to death but without death; and there were problems like unhealthy slaves becoming a nuisance. When capitalism came into being, it was enough to pay meager wages. Although he is "free" in name, a day without work is without wages; He will starve. He only has the "freedom" to decide whom to work for or who to exploit him. As time changed and "Marxism" came into existence, things changed a little, but the exploiting classes were on full alert. They want to take the worker back to the old slave days. That is why the Hindutvaists are trying to maximize working hours and abolish labor laws completely and the Indian National Congress is giving them full support. In effect, bourgeois and landlords will be one and same even though what name they holds.
//
Whenever the "Left-wing government" get chances to rule in Kerala, it has tried to do the best for the poor people. Giving houses to all the homeless people, giving old-age pensions to those who have no financial capacity, trying to provide free medical treatment to the maximum number of people, and trying to provide education to the maximum number of people are all because those in the communist movements admitting Marxism and the basis of Marxism is humanity. "Political parties" who do not admit Marxism are those who see "politics" as a mere profitable industry. Hence corruption--scam are their usual activities. Unfortunately, the COMMUNIST LEADERSHIP in India did not accept the target of Socialist India and the program of ruling India, none of the basic principles of Marxism came into effect. According to India's Constitution, sovereign power is vested in the Parliament and the Central Government. The central government is sovereign over all matters including whether states are required or not. The Indian National Congress, which controlled the central government, and the Bharatiya Janata Party, which took over the government after them, were completely anti-Marxist, and in Bengal, Tripura and Kerala, which were left-wing governments, they took a stand of complete non-cooperation whenever there was a left-wing government. According to the Constitution of India, the sovereign power lies with the Indian Parliament and the central government, so no fundamental changes can be made at the regional level, no matter how long the administration is conducted at the regional level. As socialism is possible only in a sovereign "COUNTRY", the whole of India; Only the Central Government can lead India to the goal of becoming a Socialist nation. On the other hand, the Communist Party should accept the basic objective of getting a majority in the Indian Parliament. If the communist movements in India accept such a program, at least one hundred and thirty crore people out of one hundred and forty crores of India will co-operate with it.
//
But what about the Indian National Congress? When the Communist Party came to power in Kerala in 1957, a liberation movement was launched against it and that government was dissolved using the Central Government. And that red flag politics should not exist in India under any circumstances; And that the Indian working class should not, for any reason, be freed from the extreme hunger and perpetual poverty they suffer. The position of the Congress is that it should always remain in the grip of Brahminism and the hell under four--caste system. Even after 1950s, "Party leaders" have decided to continue with the position of 1950 regardless of how miserable the situation of the Communist parties in India has become for 74 years hard work. The reason is that it does not accept that the rule of the exploiting class exists. And there is no need for Marxism. Because Karl Marx formulated the philosophy of "Marxism" only for a non-exploitative social system. Neither Lenin, who founded the Soviet Union, nor Mao Zedong, China, seemed to turn to the idea of promoting capitalism.
//
For a long time since 1950s, the political position adopted by the Communist parties in India is to promote the capitalist system and to stand for the position that the working class has no class enemies in every sense. Therefore, it is very difficult for the communist parties to stand against capitalism. The Communist Party can work only according to the existing facts in any country. The existing constitution also recognizes socialism in India. Their votes are their endorsement of the social change desired by the vast majority of people in a democracy. The specialty of democracy is that it allows them to teach things.
//
When the monarchy existed, it was the king's dominion or interests over the people. It has almost been wiped off the face of the earth. Democracy is the system that has come into existence instead. What needs to come into existence there is actually the supremacy of the people. But when the monarchy existed, it was really the rule of the rich (feudal lords). Even though the monarchy is gone, the dominance of the wealthy continues. The basis of the capitalist system is the domination of capital or the domination of capitalists (bourgeois). The basis of the capitalist system is the domination of capital or the domination of capitalists. Capitalism places money above everything else. In the Communist Manifesto itself, Marx points out that “the bourgeoisie has overthrown all human values and placed selfishness, money over them. Instead, the view of Marxism is that the rule of the people or the workers should come into existence. "Marxism" puts forward the ideas for that. The efforts of those who stand for capitalism lie in how to stop it.
//
The communist movement started working in India from 1920-25. In a very short period of 25-30 years time, it grew into the Communist Party of India by 1950. It is known that in the 1952 elections there were 32 communist members in the Indian Parliament. Until then, the goal was a socialist system. The present state of things is not even considering the downfall that occurred when such a goal was abandoned and the path of co-operation with the exploiting classes was adopted. Without the goal of socialism, there is no need for the philosophy of Marxism; It has been telling by me to the followers of progressive movements through social media that the Left cannot even exist in India for many years now; There is no other way to convince the communist Party leaders. If the Communist parties are not ready to change the "PARTY PROGRAM", the result of 2019, 24 will continue for further years of future General Elections (2029, 34, 39, 44...) also. Unfortunately, there is no scope for such a change. As decided at the last 23rd Party Congress held in April 2022, the 2025 Party Congress will also have only a "Decision to Strengthen the Party". That would only mean strengthening Indian capitalism as the method of action of PB is only to escape from the scene.
//07 05 2024//
