620. A REQUEST BEFORE THE COMMUNIST PARTIES IN INDIA - CPI(M) AND CPI. KINDLY ADMIT "MARXISM" AS PROMOTING CAPITALISM CANNOT BE CONSIDERED AS MARXISM.
//
When "SOCIALISM" becomes party program, it is also necessary to foster scientific thinking in society. When the position of "the free development of capitalist society" adopted, the need for Marxism itself disappeared. It lasted for a very long time.
//
Only if there are the target (Party Program) of SOCIALISM as working
program, the justice and science of SOCIALISM can be taught the public and working class. But it is impossible to convince the CPIM leaders the necessity of SOCIALISM as Party Program.
//
"All
the existing social laws" are created by exploiters since the period of
slavery system and even the HOOLIGANISM against Hon. C J I GAVAI is
based on "MANUSMRUTI". According to "MANUSMRUTI", anything which the
"KING" cannot be decided, there should be formed "BRAHMIN SABHA" and
only "BRAHMINS" can decide anything. This only will change when the
Party Program socialism is accepted as when admitting SOCIALISM, the
fight against all ANTI SOCIAL LAWS are starting. But only if
"socialism" is the working program can its justice and scientific be
conveyed to the people. Communist parties with a hundred years of
history have to work hard for years just to accept socialism.
//
The
Communist Parties in India have pinned all their hopes in the Indian
National Congress without understanding what "Marxism" is. It is
enough to understand that it is a philosophy of humanity. What they
don't know that the Indian National Congress
is caused for the Hindutva BJP rule in India. What is the "business"
behind it that made Sonia Gandhi the richest woman in the world. Even
from the stupid roles played by the Congress in Kerala, it is not clear
what the Congress is?.....The CPI (M) and CPI "Party Congreses" has
proven that Party Congresses are not a solution for anything; all the
past "party congresses" of the CPI(M) and CPI parties have proven that.
N
//
The
things Harihara Kurup says should have end with Harihara Kurup itself.
That is the position adopted by the Communist movements in India.
Accepting Marxism only means accepting socialism. That is not possible,
and the stance taken by the Communist movement in India since 1950s is
that it should not abandon the promotion of capitalism and accept that
socialism in Indian model will not admit. That would mean the result
of complete demise the Communist movement in India. That is what all
reactionaries want including BJP and INC. Marxism and socialism have
the capacity to overcome them all. But the basic issue is that socialism
will not be accepted through democratic means. No matter how simply
explains what democracy is, no one will understand it. In democracy,
"political power" that had vested solely in the king have shifted to
every citizen. No one understands the "revolution" in it. Humanity
cannot go back to history again where in only "ARMED REVOLUTION"
relevant in MONARCHY . No one, including EMS, understands that.
Because EMS and K. Damodaran did not understand what democracy,
Communist parties would not accept democracy and ask the people to vote
for socialism in democracy. The ranks accept whatever they hear. The
position of those who have decided that the Communist movement is only
for capitalism lies in the fact that the nuisance of now 76-year-old
Harihara Kurup will not last long. They must continue to kill the great
man Karl Marx using the image of Marx itself. That's what happens when
the ideas that were formulated to eliminate capitalist exploitation are
completely abandoned.
//
The main problem is that they don't know what capitalism is. Capitalism is not about allowing private sector industry if getting the opportunity to govern a "state" in India. In India, capitalism is a dirty "political industry" run by bourgeois parties like the Congress, BJP etc. The lack of clarity on this issue is due to a lack of understanding of the fundamental tenet of Marxism, "All recorded history is the history of class struggles." Do anything for money. Foster all anti-social forces including corruption and communalism. There is nothing wrong with allowing the private sector to participate in socialist commodity production, as in China. But the money of private capitalists should not interfere in politics. The Chinese Communist Party is careful in that regard, so that capitalists do not dominate there.
//
Socialism is only possible in a country that has "sovereignty". In India, socialism cannot be established without a majority in the Indian Parliament. If people are taught what socialism is, the Left will gain a majority in the Indian Parliament. But the stance of the communist parties in India is that there is no problem of socialism in India. So they placed their full confidence in INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS for the entire future in India.
//
WITHOUT ADMITTING "SOCIALIST INDIA", "LEFT PARTIES" CANNOT EXIST IN INDIA. OTHERWISE, BJP WILL SWALLOW EVERYBODY. ADMITTING "INDIAN CONSTITUTION" IS ENOUGH AND MORE FOR IT.
Nobody considering that behind "INDIAN CONSTITUTION", the hard work and expectations of Dr B R AMBEDKKAR resting. Actually DR AMBEDKKAR was the actual representative of INDIAN WORKING CLASS. Article 14 and 15 of Indian Constitution insists the "EQUALITY" of every Indian Citizen which only those admitting MARXISM can be implemented in its true spirit.
//
MARXISM
admits all are human beings. In DEMOCRACY only citizen. Can you
identify the caste of oxygen, water, earth, rice, wheat, electricity,
sun rays?????? Can you identify what is the caste of Indian currency? If
your mind is clear, you can admit MARXISM is right. If the mind is
good, everyone will agree that Marxism is correct. Because there are no
caste-religion differences among those who produce all the essential
goods. Therefore, there are no caste-religion differences in the essential goods either. //
When requesting to the Communist Parties (CPI(M); CPI, to admit MARXISM means to admit "SOCIALISM" which MARXISM admitting as Party Program. It is a fact that since 1950s, undivided Communist Party had decided to postpone SOCIALISM and to promote Indian Capitalism should be changed. No
one else will do what those who accept Marxism do. Unless socialism is
adopted as the party program, it encourages all the reactionary ideas
and all the bourgeois vulgarities of capitalism. It includes the
dominance of money, corruption, communalism, and cruelties against women etc. There is no need for Marxism unless it is to establish socialism. That was what Lenin himself pointed out in his (1901) work "What should be Done?" that not accepting socialism would only mean burying Marxist ideas. That has been became true in India for a long 75 years since 1950. The late former CPI(M) General Secretary Sitaram Yechury had said during the 2021 Bihar Assembly elections that "only the Indian National Congress can save India." "Arsha Bharata" should be proud as Indian culture," a CPI leader said in an interview with a news channel in 2017 and the statement by a CPI(M) Politburo member that conflict-based materialism is not applicable to India and that there are no permanent class enemies is clear evidence of this.
//
The
truth is that they don't know anything about Marxism, capitalism, or
feudalism. The democracy and federal system prevailing in India are
not understood. The fact that the sovereignty of India lies with the
Indian Parliament is part of democracy. Thinking about armed revolution
and working class dictatorship, which are only relevant in a
monarchy, and thinking that feudalism exists in India is either
ignorance or mental illness. Feudalism is monarchy. There is no
monarchy anywhere in India. What is thought to exist now is the monopoly
on land, which is part of capitalism. As was done in Kerala, the
limits of land ownership can be decided in individual states or by
passing a law in Parliament. No one except those who accept Marxism will
do that. Because domination of the land is essential for the
exploitation of the poor. No one understands the "change" or
"revolution" in which political sovereignty, which was vested solely in
the king in a monarchy, is transferred to each citizen in a democracy.
Only a mental illness allows the transfer of the country's public assets
to private individuals, because that is another form of looting public
assets. Any child can understand that public sector institutions entrust
private capitalists with the task of extracting massive corruption from
them. In India, the poor people are being deceived by the Communist
Party, which is responsible for all the economic and spiritual
exploitation, corruption, and communalism of capitalism. It is not
understood that by not accepting socialism, Hindutva BJP is actually
promoting. Therefore, the tragedy that ensues is that the Communist
Party itself ceases to exist and the party's leadership, including Dr.
Thomas Isaac, Shailaja Teacher, and M. Swaraj, who are role models for
public workers, are defeated in the elections. K Sudhakaran, an
antiquities fraudster who should not be in the public field under any
circumstances; the success of people like Rahul Mangkootam will lead to
the demise of democracy itself.
//
While
giving Party Class about "SURPLUS VALUE THEORY", without stressing
actual expenditure, we cannot count "profit" or "balance income" of
bourgeois. Without understanding anything about "MARXISM" somebody
conducting "PARTY CLASSES" and the same become
comedy or time waste. That is the cause of the poor stage of "Party" as
a whole of India. Nobody considering except means of existence, and
they will do their routine duty as party work. They are not bothered
about a "COMMUNIST PARTY: promoting CAPITALISM. //
It is on this basis that the Communist movements in India have placed their full trust in the exploiting class political leadership of the Indian National Congress. The reason why the Communist Party of India is not contesting seats that would secure a majority in the Indian Parliament is because it places all its hopes on the Indian National Congress. The fact that India as a whole does not contest elections is only because it has completely abandoned the philosophy of Marxism. No hurt should be effected to bourgeois in any way, as it is presumed that the "CORPORATES" will protect India in future. That is the reason giving full support for privatizing each and every public assets. Even though "STRIKES" will conduct every year, the same is not against anybody as CAPITALISM should be protected in every aspects. During the 24th Party Congress of the CPI(M) held in April 2025, All all these facts were brought to the attention of those who wanted the Communist movement to exist throughout India through social media. It was not reached anywhere in India because "HARIHARAKURUP" only an ordinary citizen and no one feel the necessity of the existence of Communist Party in India along with MARXIAN ideology. The Communist Party leaders placed their full confidence in capitalism along with Indian National Congress.
//
Communist
parties can only work according to the circumstances prevailing in any
country. Because everything is always subject to change, SOCIALISM can
be implemented in India in the way the Indian Constitution intends.
According to Paragraph 6.5 of the CPI(M) Party Program, the public sector
has a crucial place in the economy of "People's Democracy. Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution stipulate equality in all
respects for Indian citizens. In making such a decision, it is also
acknowledging respect for Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, who was the true
representative of the Indian working class. The
Communist movement in India adopted an anti-socialist stance for 75
years starting in 1950, which caused the Hindutva comunalism to gain
dominance in India. Without socialism becoming party program, it is
impossible to combat Hindutva communalism or bring the Indian people to a
scientific perspective. But the CPI(M) PB's stance is that it will
never allow that.
//
The Communist parties in India - CPI(M) and CPI are requesting that Marxism may kindly be accepted. That is the only request I can submit. The reason why communist parties do not currently functioning on the basis of Marxism is because they do not understand what Marxism is. Marxism fell out of field when it was decided to "promote capitalism". If that is to be resolved, socialism must be accepted as the party program. Otherwise, Communist parties will not have the support of the Indian working class, farmers, and ordinary people. If that is accepted, Hindu communalism will not be a problem for Marxism. At present the Party leaders not convinced that what exists is an exploitative class regime. That is the reason that "THERE ARE NO CLASS ENEMIES". What disappears there is the "class struggle theory" completely.
//
"Capitalism" should be understood as the domination of capital or money. That is why it is generally said to be the domination of capitalists. What came in its place is the rule of the people or "democracy". The rule of the people is socialism, which becomes the rule of "society". (Where humanity becomes the basis instead of money). Although capitalists speak of the rule of the people, they mean the rule of their own money. Its ancient form was the rule of the king or monarchy. The Communist Parties of India (CPI(M); CPI) are stern in "capitalism" as the domination of capital or money only should exist in India; as they will not ask "vote" for socialism. The Indian National Congress, Hindutva BJP, etc. are asking for votes for the dominance of capitalists. That is their stance deadly against socialism. The communist parties also take the same stance. The Indian Constitution, on the other hand, recognizes a socialist-democratic system.
//
Even
though accepts the position that only the "Indian National Congress can
save India", there are not the position that the political leadership
of Indian bourgeoisie, including BJP as "CLASS ENEMIES". That is the
basis of the position that there are no class enemies. But what about
the exploiting classes? They are all on the same position - Working
class politics should not exist in India for any reason. That is,
wherever working class
political candidates contest in India, the exploiting class conspires
to defeat them. No matter how many benefits are provided without
bringing people into working-class politics or socialist ideals,
fundamental changes will not occur in anyone. While socialist ideas were
in the field of action, those who were close to the Communist movement
were mentally close. There will be no change in them. None of them are
joining the party for temporary gains - they are joining the Communist
Party for a better social system. They would be willing to make any
sacrifice. A state without suffering and poverty. That state disappeared
when they decided to promote capitalism. Without understanding that, no
one can be permanently kept with the Communist movement, even with
benefits. That is why despite ruling Bengal for a long time, there has
been no permanent political change among the people. In the current
situation, there will be no political change in Bengal. That is why
there will be no change in what are considered "UDF" constituencies in
Kerala. //
This is due to a mistake made by the "party masters" of the 1950s. At least learn lessons from the collapse of the last 75 years. The "leaders" also don't understand why the Congress, BJP, and all the other reactionaries are united when "Communist candidates" should not win anywhere in India. The reason is simply because they don't understand Marxism. Accepting Marxism means accepting Socialism. There is no other goal there, because there is no room for doubt that the existing exploitative class rule is to be ended once and for all. The present stand is that there are no exploitation anywhere in social life. The most appropriate way to do that is through modern parliamentary democracy, which is recognized worldwide. Monarchies that required armed revolution have disappeared all over the world.
//
India is not "KERALA". Kerala alone is not enough. There should be a left-wing Government in India. For that, the CPI(M) must be accepted as a socialist India. It is enough to accept the Indian Constitution. Com. Pinarayi Vijayan will never allow that either. His stance is that India should be ruled by anyone (BJP/Congress). His stance is that there should be no changes in India except in Kerala. It happens only because Marxism is not understood. But nothing can be done. It has to change. That comrade has not understood that everything is always subject to change. Even India in its current form will not last long. The Sangh Parivar will not allow that either. He doesn't understand that either. The stance that there are no class enemies is because he doesn't understand class contradictions. If he understands that, he will abandon the stance of promoting capitalism. That too is impossible. Com. M A Baby is poor. Even if one is very poor (innocent), he can't do anything. If
it is found " right", it should be stick to it. 31 Comrades including
Comrade EMS, formed the CPI(M) in 1964 by leaving the old CPI National
Council which was admitting that Indian National Congress representing
the "BOURGEOIS AND LAND LORDS OF INDIA". The "70-member majority" in the
then 101-member National Council later proved that the "majority" is
not always on the side of truth. Others did not understood that what
Comrade EMS was
considering at that time was the class structure of the Indian National
Congress. Those who did not understand the "class structure of the
Congress" presumed that the "Indian National Congress" was just the
name. The exploiting classes in India will have no objection to being
called "Indian National Congress" or "BJP" because no one understands
that the two names are two sides of the same coin. This point was
accepted by Comrade Prakash Karat in 2016. But his stance was later
proven to be without understanding the real "class structure". The
decisions taken at the 24th Party Congress of the CPI(M) led the party
to the conclusion that the Indian National Congress should govern India.
It was because those who did not understand Marxism came to lead the
Communist movement that Indian politics fell into the hands of Hindutva
terrorists since the 1950s. Despite Russia's industrial backwardness and
the fact that it was an imperial state, Lenin did not hesitate to
embrace the goal of socialism.
//
Giordano
Bruno was burned alive by the Roman Inquisition for saying that the
Earth is spherical. Harihara Kurup is being treated the same way because
he took the stance that Marxism is not about promoting capitalism.
However, I can't decline the truth.
I am a proud person who was an ordinary party member of the Communist
Party of India (Marxist) for forty years (1985-2025) for the socialist
system. Only someone can be a party member, but the party decides
how they should act. Party consciousness is knowledge of the philosophy
of Marxism, knowledge of the groups of people for whom that philosophy
was formulated, knowledge of the suffering of those groups, and a
commitment to resolving it. Karl Marx even had to give up his own
country's citizenship to stand up for what was right. In any case, the
CPI(M) cannot take away Harihara Kurup's Indian citizenship. //
The stance that socialism will not be accepted no matter how much the Communist movement suffers is only merely firm declaration that it does not accept Marxism. In reality, it is siding with the class enemies. The late former CPI(M) General Secretary Sitaram Yechury once said, "Only the Indian National Congress can save India." The facts are that the CPI(M) and CPI parties have fully accepted it. Not knowing what capitalism,
socialism, or democracy is does not justify the cruelty being inflicted on a country of one hundred and forty crore people.
//
A senior party leader once said that Union Home Minister Amit Shah is "not a person who just became a minister through breaking the tiles of the house". This was said when there was a controversy over inviting Amit Shah to inaugurate the Nehru Trophy boat race in Kerala. That is, he meant that Amit Shah is a Union Minister elected by the people. There is no need to test the entire blood of a person's body to understand his disease. Just a drop of blood is enough to test. Just one opinion on a subject is enough to understand a person's entire personality. The Supreme Court of India has ruled that Amit Shah should not enter the state of Gujarat due to his role in the 2002 Gujarat riots for certain period. The main culprits of the Gujarat riots became the rulers of India only because the Indian National Congress was in power at the time and because the Congress was mentally in favor of the Gujarat riots. Hindutva extremists are currently ruling India simply because India's communist leaders cannot understand things that ordinary people can understand.
//
"There are two issues involved in a senior CPI(M) leader's statement that Union Home Minister Amit Shah is "not a person who has become a minister by breaking tiles of the house". One, the Hindutva BJP is a political party that accepts democracy; inviting Home Minister Amit Shah for an event in Kerala should be welcomed by a working class movement. Secondly, there are no problems with the theory of class struggle that Marxism accepts on that issue. This issue played a role in the inclusion of the issue of Hindutva and BJP "not fascist" in the political resolution of the CPI(M)'s 24th party congress. The basic issue here is to take a position as favorable to the Hindutva BJP as much as possible. In no way should anything happen that would be politically harmful to them.
//
Of course, to understand the "class struggle theory", one needs a
third eye of goodness in the mind. Because no one is cruel because
just they have wealth, nor is anyone good just because they don't have
wealth. Engels, who helped Marx the most, was the son of a rich man
and a businessman. The Communist leader in Kerala, Comrade EMS, was a
landlord and a Brahmin. There are those who, despite being very rich,
became poor by donating all their wealth to the poor. (St. Simon of
France). In that list, Sri. Budha was a Prince. But Karl Marx's
extraordinary talent caused the discovery that the conflicts
between rich and poor has existed since the days of slavery and
private property. It was because Karl Marx had it and hence, Engels
said of Marx, "He saw from a great height and a great distance, like no
other." It is the realization that there are people who work and suffer
perpetual poverty; it has existed since prehistoric times; that makes
Marx "hold the bar higher than anyone else." The position of Marx
above all other great men is that he provides guidance for humanity as a
whole.
//
No
matter how much explained, still can't understand the danger of the
stance that "there are no class enemies." Even though class enemies are
working in whatever way they can to ensure that there is no red flag
politics in India, the Communist leadership in India does not understand
that the entire written history disclosed by Karl Marx is the history
of class struggles. The danger of that stance is that the Communist
movement in India
is disappearing completely. In the current situation, the Left
government is not just in Kerala. It is believed that only the
right-wing media in Kerala is anti-Left. It is not understood that it is
just a face of the exploiting classes. This does not mean that there
will be no third or fourth round in Kerala. The situation in Bengal,
which has ruled continuously for thirty-four years, should be taken into
account. They don't realize that "India" is our country. They don't
understand the horror of Hindutva communalism. They don't even
understand what Marxism is. What is meant here is the stance of the
CPI(M) and CPI parties in India that there is no question of abandoning
the promotion of capitalism. //
What
the Communist leaders of the 1950s, Comrades K. Damodaran and EMS, did
not understand was not only that the entire written history was history
of class struggles. contradiction-based materialism and class
antagonisms, but also Marx's fundamental discovery is that the
environment determines consciousness; consciousness does not determine
the environment. Part of that is the discovery that a country's economic
system deciding its political and cultural superstructure. These
matters were made clear in the work "A Contribution to Political
Economy", which Marx prepared before writing "Das Capital". This issue
was presented distortedly in K. Damodaran's "Marxist Classes". But that
Comrade did not understand the issue. Otherwise, he would not have
decided to promote Indian capitalism, which was built on Brahminism and
feudalism. The monarchy was maintained by feudal lords. The capitalist
system is maintained by capitalists or their money power. In India, it
is the Indian National Congress and the BJP that protect Indian
Corporates. In return, they will protect the Congress and the BJP. But
no matter how much the Communist Party takes the stance that capitalism
should grow, the Corporates, Congress, and BJP will not allow the
Communist Party to survive in India. The philosophy of "Marxism" is
entirely designed to establish all of this. It is quite natural that
Pinarayi Vijayan, Prakash Karat, or Sitaram Yechury do not understand
things that comrades K Damodaran and EMS do not understand. But what
happens when we ignore the specific points made in all of Lenin's works
is what is happening to the Communist Party of India, which has a
history of over a hundred years.
//
The entire written history was history
of class struggles. In India it was in the form of Arya invasion through killing or making slaves of "DRAVIDIANS". Aryas
were claimed that they were "DEWAS" and Dravidians were "ASURAS'. The
evidence we could get from Harappa; Mohanjedaro culture. Their leader
was "BHARADA" and he made his capital at "INDRAPRASTHA" at Delhi. Aryas
killed thousands of Dravidas and after they made them SLAVES. Nobody
will become slaves by themselves. Aryans were minority in population but
were ferocious in nature. They knew use of horse and would attack
sharply and destroy non Aryans who were the real inhabitants in India.
The WONDERFUL THINGS WE CAN SEE IN OUR OLD TEMPLES AND OTHER PLACES MADE
IN STONE which also part of Indian culture was built on the blood and
skeleton of dravidian slaves. The DRAVIDIAN culture are far; far away
when compared to "ARYA" culture which is based on 4 CASTE system. The
EMPIRE MAHABALI; whose kingdom was known as everybody are equals; was
also part of that. In India; Aryas came; Alexander came; Mugals came;
and foreigners came. We should admit all of these and they all helped to
make the present India. So India is a country of "UNITY IN DIVERSITY"
and trying to destroy even any of them make hurt the social life. Now
they all Indian Citizens and should be considered as equals. Anybody
wants to go from India; that must be ARYAS first. The
evidence discovered from Harappa- Mohanjedaro taught us also this. The
stone temples all over India had the work of only slaves and they were
only Dravidians of encient India. Whether we could decide that they had
themselves became slaves? Or Aryans killed a lot and balance kept as
slaves? Aryans described themselves as Dewas and Dravidians were called
as "Asuras". Dewa - Asura war was actually war against Dravidians.
"Asuras" are old Dravidians.
//
CPI(M)
Politburo members, including Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan, do not admit
the existence of class differences, class conflicts, and class struggle. It is the reason happening in Kerala that only "development" of the country is necessary while the existing class structure is based on exploitation on the base of economy as well as spiritual exploitation going on. That is the stance that only the end of Hindutva rule in India is
enough. Not only that, in Kerala and Bengal, and the whole of India,
everyone will not vote for the Left parties for development, above class
differences. That is a complete denial of the fact that the entire
written history of humanity
is the history of class struggles, which is the cornerstone of Marxism.
They are unable to understand the unity of the entire India of class
enemies who oppose working-class politics. The complete negation of
Marxism that has occurred due to the promotion of capitalism for the
past 75 years since 1950s. And the fact that exploitative class
politics, which deadly against Marxism and the working class politics
should not be a political force, continues to dominate India. It makes
no difference whether it is the Indian National Congress, Hindutva or
any other religion, because Marxism is against all anti-social forces.
//
Without
understanding that the Indian Parliament is the sovereign power in
India, CPIM PB is considering each state as separate unit and think
that India can be ruled by any bourgeois political party. This was
happened due to the poor vision of Com.EMS as he had stressed in his
book, "ARTS AND SCIENCE OF WORKING CLASS POLITICS, PAGE 53, as if get
continuous ruling in a state can implement socialism, while major
political power vested only in Central Government. Even Income Tax of
every person will go to Central Government. But
34 years continuous ruling in Bengal had proved that Comrade EMS had
mistaken, because to establish SOCIALISM, sovereign political powers
inevitable. There are very little powers vested with STATE GOVERNMENTS,
and almost all political powers vested with PARLIAMENT AND CENTRAL
GOVERNMENT. CPI(M) Party Program not
considering such things. But CPI(M) PB will only
follow the words of EMS for ever. While the exploiting classes are
trying to bring the whole of India under their control, the Leftists are
sticking to each "unit". While the CPI(M) stands on the understanding
that India should be governed by the Indian National Congress, no one
will vote for the Left in the parliamentary elections. If that
situation is to change, there must be a situation in India where people
are asked to vote for a socialist system. No one will vote for the Left
to promote capitalism, because the exploiting classes across India are
ready to implement capitalism in all its forms.
