622. INDIAN "COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS" WILL NOT GO FORWARD UNDER THE CONCEPT THAT "THERE ARE NO CLASS ENEMIES".

 622. INDIAN "COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS" WILL NOT GO FORWARD UNDER THE CONCEPT THAT "THERE ARE NO CLASS ENEMIES".

//

 

Since 1969 I have been a member of the Communist Party for the SOCIALIST SOCIETY. . Now 76 years old and being an ordinary party member for 55 years. When I became a party member, I did not know that the undivided Communist Party of India had been standing for the growth of Indian capitalism since the 1950s. Since learning about it in a party class in 2002, I have been going on internal struggle as possible against it. There is no sign of the CPI and CPI(M) leadership abandoning the promotion of capitalism to this day (9 05 2026). The fact that I cannot say anything to anyone except through social media also makes them helpless. Comrades who only view what is said on social media with complete enmity as they can't understand about criticism. The leaders of the CPI(M) and CPI do not even think that this is a matter for the future of 140 crore Indian people. "The mistake will be corrected" is said without understanding where the "mistake" is.

//

Even in 2026, in India, a country with a population of one hundred and forty crores and a history of over a hundred years, the Communist movements in India do not have a single state in power. Since 2002, have been demanding a change in CPI(M) PARTY PROGRAM, which focuses on the free development of capitalist society, as there is no doubt that Marxism is not for capitalism For many years, requesting during every "PARTY CONGRESS" that a Socialist India through "PEOPLES DEMOCRACY" should be the party program. The comrades in the CPI(M) Politburo are not convinced that Marxism is not for capitalism. At least changes were expected at the 24th Party Congress held in April 2025. nothing happened.

There is not a single member in the Bengal Assembly, which had a very large majority, for many years. Finally, the Government in Kerala also disappeared. At least now, I hope that the comrades in the CPI(M) Politburo will realize that Marxism is not for capitalism.

//

Even in 2026, in India, a country with a population of one hundred and forty crores and a history of over a hundred years, the communist movements in India do not have a single state in power. I am requesting the CPI(M) leaders since 2002, the CPI(M) party program, which focuses on the free development of capitalist society, a change in its program, as there is no doubt that Marxism is not for capitalism. For many years, I have been pleading during its Party Congresses that a "Socialist India through "PEOPLES DEMOCRACY" should be the party program. The comrades in the CPI(M) Politburo are not convinced that Marxism is not for capitalism. At least at the Party Congress held in April 2025, changes were expected. Nothing happened. There was not a single member in the Bengal Assembly, which had a very large majority, for many years. Finally, the Government in Kerala also disappeared. At least now, I hope that the comrades in the CPI(M) Politburo will realize that Marxism is not for capitalism.

//

While CLASS ENEMIES going on through their acute lies against SOCIALIST IDEOLOGY and WORKING CLASS POLITICS just like THUNDER STORMS, "COMMUNIST LEADERS OF INDIA" who pretends admitting MARXISM stern in their position that there are NO CLASS ENEMIES and doing their all acts promoting CAPITALISM and EXPLOITERS. It is impossible to exist COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS in India as nobody can do anything against them to admit MARXISM.

//

The position of the Communist parties in India is that the "Indian National Congress should rule India, as the Left does not have candidates to govern India in the Indian parliamentary elections. While Communist parties adopt the stance of "there are no class enemies", exploiting classes are stern that "Communist parties should not exist in India in any way". That is what is happening all over India including Bengal. No one will vote for the Communist parties to rule Congress in India. That is what happened in the 2019; 2024 elections. The current situation will not change in 2029 either.

//

Don't realized the danger of the position "there are no class enemies". When declining the "CLASS STRUGGLE THEORY" totally failed to understand that the philosophy of "MARXISM" completely rejecting when taking the position that there are "NO CLASS ENEMIES". Don't realized the danger of promoting capitalism. It is not understood that "CLASS COLLABORATION" is not MARXISM.

Don't understand Marxism.

//

Even Senior Comrades say with great joy, "Our party is not there." The reason for their joy is that they don't need to know anything about the affairs there to be solved. Understanding that "humanity" is the basis of Marxism and if we are to understand that the target of Marxism is to save the lives of the millions of people in India who suffer the cruelty of poverty and exploitation, we must have at least a shred of conscience. There is not even the sense of INDIA is our country. While the goal of promoting capitalism taken up, everyone's goal became only selfishness, which is the basis of capitalism. When saying one Hariharakurup "that Marxism is only for socialism", those in the leadership of the Communist Party (Marxist) do not need to consider it. They will not change their positions at all. They will continue as long as they can somehow continue in leadership. That's all. They will never admit that only "socialism" the target of Communist Party, and that sticking to capitalism will result in the complete collapse of the Communist Party. They are not convincing the "Hindutva terrorism" going forward with destroying all qualities of Indian Constitution and democracy. As they haven;t know about MARXISM, they don't know what is the power of the Indian working class if we accept socialism, but they will not be convinced. Since they have no enmity with BOURGEOIS and their political parties, they do not have the issue of "class enemies". Only those who have read at least the biography of Karl Marx will understand why that humanitarian spent his life. Actual "party" is existing only which was what SOCIALISM were the target, and the same is also vanishing through promoting capitalism. There is no way to convince them that the party will not make even a little progress in India without socialism becoming the goal again.

//

The working class should not be a political force in the world for any reason. That is the stand of exploiting classes all over the world and they are insistent that the working people can only live in perpetual poverty. That is the hooliganism that the American President, Donald Trump, is showing towards the small country of Venezuela, a South American country. As part of that, the Indian bourgeoisie is making every effort to prevent the Communist movement from existing in India. Even democracy is not something the bourgeoisie is interested in. But it cannot be denied. Venezuela has a Government elected by its people. Donald Trump has no reason to take a stand against that. However, it is being unnecessarily harmful. The Hindutva BJP and Congress are of the same opinion that the Indian exploiting classes should not have red flag politics in India. That is why the Congress gave up a Parliamentary Constituency so that the BJP could win in Thrissur, even though it does not have power in a single Panchayat in Thrussur District. Even if no one votes, they will win by manipulating the voting machines.

//

The danger of the stance that there are "NO CLASS ENEMIES.

//

Kerala Chief Minister Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan is the leader of the Left Front, which the people of Kerala gave a very good majority and won. The stand taken by the Congress leadership in Kerala is that they will not be allowed him to rule in any way. They attacked him directly to assassinate him including by attacking on the road and on the plane, and by filing a case in the Supreme Court despite knowing that "Lavalin" was not a defendant in the case. There was a deliberate attempt to attribute the gold smuggling operation led by Swapna Suresh and supported by the BJP on Pinarayi Vijayan. They deliberately tried to defame his daughter and son, who had not done anything illegal. Since none of this was illegal in any way, the leaders of the Indian National Congress in Kerala were unable to give Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan even a scratch. Com. Pinarai Vijayan is unable to grasp that why the opposition, including the Indian National Congress, and all the newspapers that side with them are launching such a fierce attack against a Chief Minister who elected by the people in huge majority. He has worked only for the development of Kerala in an efficient manner. However, it is a fact that Pinarayi Vijayan has no animosity or hostility towards the opposition in any way. He will forgive whatever the opposition does, including killing party comrades and earning money through any number of nefarious means, including corruption. Even during election campaigns, he never talks about anything other than development. Former Chief Minister Oommen Chandy himself said, "Pinarayi doesn't even talk about things that are worth talking about." That is the greatness of Kerala's Chief Minister, Com. Pinarayi Vijayan. He does not see anyone as an opponent or an enemy. No matter how miserable the defeats in the elections, he is not willing to make trouble for them by mentioning any anti-social actions they may take, as no one is an enemy.

//

But what Com.Pinarai didn't understand was that since he was a leader of the Communist Party (Marxist), the Communist movement should not exist in India is the reason that the Congress and the bourgeois newspapers that support them are launching a fierce attack against him. For Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan, there is no such thing as "class enemies". Comrade EMS's position is that "capitalism should grow freely". He will not deviate even a little from the position taken by Comrade EMS on all matters. "Our country" means only "Kerala" to him. Not "India". The stance of Politburo members, including Pinarayi Vijayan, is that since Kerala is "our country", India should be governed by whoever it wants. Since EMS's only goal was the development of Kerala, and the country "India" was not even in EMS's imagination, he did not need to know anything about India other than Kerala. Moreover, Comrade EMS had said that "socialism" through parliamentary means even social reforms are not possible. This is because class consciousness; class contradictions; and class struggle were things that Comrade EMS did not understand and hence, that Comrade EMS adopted the position of "free growth of capitalist society" is concerning deeply Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan and no matter other than CAPITALISM. Since he has no idea about class enemies, he does not know against which class Karl Marx said "the dictatorship of the working class" was needed, and why. He also fails to understand that the fierce attack on the Left government and its leader Pinarayi Vijayan is aimed at eliminating the communist movement in India, including in Kerala.

//

Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan does not understand class consciousness, class contradictions, or class struggle, as Comrade EMS did not understand them. That is why we do not know what real working class politics is. That is why "left politics" in Kerala is limited to the development of Kerala only. That is why the Indian National Congress, the political leadership of the Indian bourgeoisie, is attacking Comrade Pinarayi Vijayan on the basis that the working class should not be a political force in India. It's not just that there are no political counter--attacks, there is even no resistance. It's not just a situation in Kerala. It's a situation that applies to the whole of India, including Bengal. The exploiting classes will be united to ensure that the "Left" does not win anywhere in India. Recently, Rahul Gandhi said that the RSS and CPI(M) are their enemies. The situation has arisen due to the long-standing promotion of exploitative class politics, such that no one in India knows what real working class politics is. Without the acceptance of socialism as Party Program, there can be no "working class politics" in action in field. There can be no resistance to racism without the awareness that the "working class" is a class. That is impossible as long as it stands for the "free development of capitalist society." The "India Alliance" is just a place where the communist movement in India can completely disappear. It will only lead to a situation where the Left will not be able to govern "India". The fact that the entire world accepted 175 years ago by Karl Marx is still not accepted in India. Lenin had no doubts about that.

//

One must have at least a little common sense to understand that the political stance adopted by the Congress in Kerala will be adopted by the entire country, including Bengal. There should be at least one percent understanding of what working class politics is. For a very long time, capitalism was considered the only politics and the sole goal of life was survival, and hence Marxism is completely abandoned. They have nothing other than CAPITALISM. The CPI(M) leadership does not believe that the prevailing system involves both spiritual and economic exploitation. If so, there is no problem in promoting it. But neither K Damodaran nor EMS taught that in India. Therefore, when Sitaram Yechury said that only the Indian National Congress could save India, no one had any doubts. No one understood that the reason for Yechury's stance was that he realized from his experience in Bengal that the party would completely disappear.

//

"Socialism" is just a word for the CPI(M) Politburo members, who have no even a remote understanding of the lives of the poor, the oppressed by birth. "Poverty" is just a word for them. Somehow they even reached the leadership of the CPI(M). Especially if they are also "Brahmins", then anyone can guess. The excitement - the joy - that the party program of the free growth of "capitalism" gave to the "communist" leadership, starting with S. A. Dange, cannot be expressed in words. They will have no hesitation in repeatedly saying, "The party nowhere says that socialism can be established through parliamentary means." Even the word socialism is arrogant to them. The truth is that they don't even know the meaning of the words. Those who have truly enjoyed "politics" and made their own lives and the future of their children secure, need not know what India is. Kerala is their only world. It is impossible to even have the feeling that India is our country.

//

The issue of farmers in India committing suicide due to lack of value for their agricultural produce, and the issue of agricultural workers working there, will never be their issue. Since they are CPI(M) Politburo members, no one can teach them anything. Indians just have to tolerate everything. For them, the "Communist Party" is just an ordinary political party in India. Marxism calls it a "petty bourgeois political" party. That's what happened when it became part of the "India Alliance".

//

The exploiting classes all over the world have come to realize that if the entire working class in the world becomes a force, no one will be able to confront it. That should not happen for any reason. But even Marx would never expect the Communist Party to promote capitalism. No one knows that while capitalism is promoted, there is nothing politically to say to the people. Along with this, the position that only the Indian National Congress can save India. KIFB and corruption-free Kerala are saving now. We can't go on like this for long. No one should trust Harihara Kurup. But we should trust Marx.

//

The discovery that an exploiting class that have been sucking the blood of the working class existing since the days of slavery and private property system, which even led Karl Marx to formulate the philosophy of "Marxism." That is the basis of the discovery that "all written history is the history of class struggles." Marx and Engels also understood that Marx's discovery had worldwide relevance. That is the reason of their call: "Workers of all countries; unite; you have only shackles to lose; and a world without suffering and poverty to gain." Unfortunately, the stance of the "Communist" leaderships in India, which have worked in India for over a hundred years, is that, in " India ", with a population of over one hundred and forty crores, does not have the "working class" as that Marx identified. They have no enmity towards anyone. They have no doubt placing their full confidence in "INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS" even though they claim that they have the history of one century. Because they haven't convinced whether there are any kind of CLASS STRUCTURE or CLASS CONTRADICTIONS existing in India.They only treat everyone as brothers. They also have a strong stance that India should not have a social system like that called for by Marx. It is enough if somehow the rule of Hindu communalism ends in India. They also stern that people should never vote for a socialist system in India. The "COMMUNIST" leaders of India haven't understood the relation of working class with MARXISM. And also working class of India haven't understood the purpose of "COMMUNIST" movements of India.

//

Even though the "COMMUNIST" leaders of India had heard the word "WORKING CLASS DICTATORSHIP", they hadn't understood the meaning of it and what is its purpose.

The "COMMUNIST" leadership in India had no idea what the term "WORKING CLASS DICTATORSHIP" was or why it was used, other than having heard it. In 1871, the working class in France seized power and established the "Paris Commune", but it was soon overthrown. That was why Marx said that if the working class seizes power through revolution, it will need "WORKING CLASS DICTATORSHIP" for the time being to prevent it from being overthrown by counter-revolutionaries. When Marxism was introduced to the world in the mid-19th century - the 1850s - and was embraced by the world's working class, it caused no small shock to the imperialist powers that ruled the world. The exploiting classes all over the world have come to realize that if the entire working class in the world becomes a force, no one will be able to confront it. That should not happen for any reason. The name they gave to the attack on "communism" launched by all the reactionaries of the world at that time was the war against the "communist demon". All the exploiting class forces in the world united against the socialist system. Yet, in 1917, the world's first socialist state came into being through the Great October Revolution. In a very short time, the "Soviet Union" was able to convince the world of the power of socialism. But it was Mikhail Gorbachev, the General Secretary of the "Communist" Party there, who destroyed the Soviet Union, which was the hope and enthusiasm of the world's working class.

//

Those who say that the Communist Party "stands firmly on the dictatorship of the working class" have not understood any of the changes that have occurred in the world since the time of Karl Marx. They are people who don't understand the meaning of a word, except that they have "heard some words". They don't understand democracy at all. "Political power", which was vested solely in the king during the monarchy, shifted to individual citizens when democracy implemented. Armed revolution was relevant only in the monarchy. When democracy implemented, every citizen became a political power. This was something that unthinkable in Marx's time. That is the reason, an ordinary woman "DRAOUPADI MURMU" become the Hon. PRESIDENT OF INDIA. Nobody noticed the "REVOLUTION" happened when the "MONARCHY" became history, even though they will say "everything subject to change" an important fact of MATERIALISM. If the Government has a majority of the people, there is no other power in any country above it. There was no way in monarchy to know the majority of the people. The Indian National Congress adopted "socialism" by amending the Indian Constitution in 1976. When private banks and petrol companies were nationalized, the support given to the Congress by the Indian people was a four-fifths majority. The fact is that the Indian National Congress cannot implement socialism because its class structure is that of the big bourgeoisie and landlords of India. But what was relevant there was the interest of the Indian people in a socialist system. When the Indian National Congress abandoned the goal of socialism, the Indian people also abandoned the Congress. If COMMUNIST PARTY seek the approval of the people of India for a socialist system, Communist movements will receive even greater support than they gave to the Congress. But the current situation is that if Communist movements persist in "promoting capitalism" without understanding what democracy is, the people will be helpless. They can only take the stance that they will not vote for Communist movements.

//

The work that dissolved the Soviet Union in 1991 and banned its Communist Party was done by the "Communist" leadership in India as early as the 1950s. By abandoning socialism and deciding to promote capitalism. The Communist movement in India, which began its activities in India from 1920-25 and grew within a few years, overcoming prohibition and all adverse circumstances in India. But it began to collapse when it abandoned the goal of socialism. Even after 75 years of experience, the "Communist" leaderships are not convinced that the communist movement in India cannot survive without the goal of socialism.

//

Due to the stance of "promoting capitalism" that has been in place for the past 75 years since the 1950s, even the words "Marxism" and "socialism" have been completely abandoned by the Communist leadership in India. The CPI(M) and CPI parties are moving forward in India that working-class politics has "no class enemies" in India because it promotes "capitalism". Meanwhile the BOURGEOIS and their political leadership in the firm stand that COMMUNIST POLITICS SHOULD NOT EXIST ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD AS A WHOLE, THE "COMMUNIST LEADERS" OF INDIA IN THE FIRM STAND THAT THERE ARE NO CLASS ENEMIES FOR WORKING CLASS POLITICS IN INDIA. They don't know even what the political movement "Indian National Congress" is. And no one in the world can convince them of that. The basic issue is that even the communist leaders in India in the 1950s did not understand the conflict of interests between slave and owner, and between worker and capitalist. But the communist leadership is not ready to make any change in its position now.

//

No one in the COMMUNIST PARTY could understood that the "COMMUNIST PARTY" came in power in Kerala during 1957 only due to the fact a "CONSTITUTION" which admitting democracy and adult franchise in India is existing. All citizens, including the "LAND LORD", BRAHMAN, and the DALITH "AGRICULTURAL WORKER" became equal in political power. Unfortunately, the COMMUNIST LEADERSHIP then decided that they will not implement SOCIALISM through "PARLIAMENTARY DEMOCRACY". Poor grasping power to understand actually what is "DEMOCRACY". Those who say that everything is always subject to change cannot understand any changes that occur in society. No one understood the "revolution" that occurred when political power, which had been exclusively vested in the British Queen before 1947, became vested in every citizen when democracy was implemented. No one understood the equality in democracy where Brahmin, landlord, and agricultural laborer all have one vote. Therefore, the communist parties in India decided - even with democracy, socialist transformation in the country would not be allowed. No one understood that the monarchy would never return to carry out a revolution in the future.

Even saying something by Harihara Kurup will not change the Communist Party's stance.

//

So they merely decided to promote Indian CAPITALISM and exploiters in its every meaning. And also without grasping the meaning of capitalism and "PEOPLES DEMOCRACY", merely decided to establish "PEOPLES DEMOCRACY", while promoting capitalism. Anybody knowing the meaning of the words, will be in trouble, but they can't do anything. But when use words without knowing their meaning, there will be no effect except that those who use them will become fools. That's what happened with the "people's democratic revolution" in India. But it's impossible to correct it - because "politics" is seen only as a means of livelihood.

//

The stance of the CPI's last 25th Party Congress also proves that it will continue to promote the exploitative classes, which have been in existence for the past 75 years since 1950. Perhaps they had decided to continue with the stance of CPIM, because it remained with the undivided party in the 1950s. Because the party remained in the undivided position of 1950. That means there is no danger in the position that has been maintained for the past 75 years since 1950 which neglecting MARXISM and class collaboration with bourgeois. They don't understand that what exists is the rule of the exploiting class. And they don't understand the relevance of the Communist Party. It's just a political party like other political parties. That is the reality of the "India" alliance. Even as a broad alliance to exclude the BJP, there is no need for a Communist party to adopt an Anti-Socialist stance. But the fundamental issue that India considers necessary is the "free development of capitalist society." That cannot be abandoned. That is the unwavering interest shown in giving public wealth to big capitalists. Even the old stance of the Indian National Congress was that "public sector industries are the temples of the nation." It was only when the Congress took that stance that, under the leadership of Indira Gandhi, private sector banks and petrol companies were nationalized and the word "socialism" was added to the Indian Constitution.

Following globalization, the Congress abandoned its old positions. That is why the Indian National Congress, which had a four-fifths majority in the Indian Parliament, was removed from the Government of India by the Indian people. The CPI's Party Congress also decided that the "Communist" parties in India will not accept even the stance taken by the old Indian National Congress. Both "Communist" parties have no idea what the basic issue is; What is Marxism and what is its purpose. They want only the name "COMMUNIST PARTY". Indian Working Class and common peoples will continue their present stand ignorance as a "COMMUNIST PARTY IN INDIA". INDIAN COMMUNIST MOVEMENTS WILL NOT GO FORWARD UNDER THE CONCEPT THAT "THERE ARR NO CLASS ENEMIES".

//

To establish "socialism" in India in democracy, Communist parties must accept socialism and bring its scientific nature and justice to the people. At the same time, the falsity of the reactionary ideas that lead to capitalist exploitation and spiritual exploitation must be exposed before the people. The Indian Constitution and Marxism have everything needed for that. The Indian Constitution, prepared under the leadership of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, can only be implemented by those who truly accept Marxism. Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution guarantee equality in all respects to all citizens. Article 51A(h) insisting "SCIENTIFIC TEMPER" AS "FUNDAMENTAL DUTY OF EVERY CITIZENS"; without admitting "MATERIALISM AND DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM", it is impossible to implement Article 51A(h) of Indian Constitution, which stressing "SCIENTIFIC TEMPER" should admit as "FUNDAMENTAL DUTY" of every citizens. Art.19 - freedom of opinion which enables to teach MARXISM also in public; which were prevented during monarchy, as the Constitution itself "SOVEREIGN, SOCIALIST, DEMOCRATIC, SECULAR REPUBLIC OF INDIA". We want only to follow strictly implementing the Articles of Indian Constitution, as it was prepared by Dr B R AMBEDKKAR. But the Indian National Congress or the Hindutva activists cannot do anything about this. Dr. Ambedkar resigned from Nehru's cabinet in 1951, realizing that the Indian National Congress could not implement Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution.

//

But the stance of the Communist movements in India is that socialism is not necessary in India. No matter what Marxism is said on social media, it will not reach the decision-makers. To their knowledge, working-class politics has absolutely no enemies in India. (Many people don't even know that such a thing exists as "CLASS ENEMIES"). In any case, Harihara Kurup must not say a single word to anyone before he dies, because they must keep the meaningless doubts that everyone harbors in their minds. Because the free development of capitalist society should not be altered in any way. In a democracy, everyone has political freedom and freedom of expression. Human society cannot move forward without defeating the utterly anti-social ideas of capitalism. Now the country is in the hands of anti-socialists. It is up to the Indian working class to free itself from it. The Communist parties only need to accept Marxism and socialism. But their doubts will never go away.

//

Their fear about caste system of India is only due to the ignorance of MARXISM as social science. The base of MARXISM is humanity and above 99% of common people will come with this quality without any kind of peculiarities such as caste, money etc. Com. EMS was brahmin and land lord, Ratan Tata was the most richest of India - but they also have the quality of humanity and love with actual working class and poor people. But impossible to convince Communist party leaders. The fear about caste system in India by "COMMUNIST" leaders is only due to lack of "CLASS SENSE" because while promoting BOURGEOIS it is impossible to keep CLASS SENSE, CLASS STRUGGLE ETC OF MARXISM. The role playing in "INDIA" coalition is certainly declining the CLASS STRUGGLE THEORY in total and the "politics" in it is only "FREE DEVELOPMENT OF CAPITALISM and only "INC" can save India.

//27 10 2025//