235. A REPLY TO A COMMENT:::::::::My postings are on the basis of CPIM program. In CPIM program; Para 6.2; it is stated that "CONSIDERING THE DEGREE OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT" ; THE ACTUAL FACT TO PROMOTE "CAPITALISM" IS A HIDDEN FACT; BECAUSE IF THE ACTUAL FACT PLACED THERE; THEY (THOSE PREPARED THE DRAFT) KNEW THAT THE "PROGRAM" CANNOT BE PASSED ANYWHERE. SO THEY PLAYED A TRICK; IT MUST BE HIDDEN. SO IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO DETECT THE COMMON COMRADES; WHERE IS THE FAULT. IT WILL SAY IN THE PARTY CLASS; THOSE WHO GETTING THE CLASS WILL BE ONLY THOSE REACHED IN HIGHER POSITION; AND THEY CANNOT SAY ANYTHING; OTHERWISE THEIR MEANS OF EXISTENCE WILL LOSE. BUT COM.EMS CLEARLY SAYING IN HIS BOOK (ARTS & SCIENCE OF WORKING CLASS POLITICS; Page 21; THAT FREE DEVELOPMENT OF CAPITALISM IS REQUIRED. (Please see my blog No. 125 BELOW)...
Can you understand anything what Budhadeb had done in West Bengal; I mean that capturing land from 9000 farmers and giving them to TATA for starting a Car project? And during 1957; EMS ministry of Kerala invited BIRLA to Kerala (MAVOOR RAYONS) and started BIRLA's firm at Mavoor, Kerala (Kozhikode). These was on the decisions of the leaders of SA DANGE etc. to promote capitalism during 1950s. During that period; then leaders decided to postpone SOCIALISM and to promote capitalism. Then their decision was only for a short period; but later; unfortunately; that decision was considered for ever. They were kept the decision as "TACTICS"; but, MARXISM VANISHED FROM THE FIELD. I mean; class struggle became impossible between bourgeois and working class.
Please see my Blog No.125 also (125. AT PRESENT WHAT IS "PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC REVOLUTION"? In a book of Com.EMS, (ARTS & SCIENCE OF WORKING CLASS POLITICS) (Page 53) he says that Lenin severely criticising BOURGEOIS PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM and that implementing SOCIALISM through PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM is impossible and even social changes are impossible. Here Com. EMS had happened a mistake that Lenin (In the book STATE AND REVOLUTION") actually criticising CAPITALISM and Lenin says that even "A best PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM" will be only a "WAGE SLAVERY" (WAGE COOLIE) to working class. What is "wage slavery"? In old slavery system, slaves had the benefit of protection like cattles such as food (only capable to their existences) and shelter and in capitalism, bourgeois have not such responsibilities; but the worker should work under any bourgeois to his existences and at present he has the freedom to choice to whom he can sell his manpower; otherwise he must die. Com.EMS says in the same book; (Page 21) the necessity of "FREE DEVELOPMENT OF CAPITALISM" by severe blow on FEUDALISM. Com.EMS understood only that the words of Lenin relates to PARLIAMENTARY ELECTION PROCEDURES AND FORMING OF MINISTRY only. Lenin had decided to establish SOCIALISM in the dynasty of Tsar' where FEUDALISM IN ITS ALL EVILNESS and also the CAPITALISM of then Russia was in a pathetic condition only. Lenin was not ready to admit CAPITALISM even in that condition and reiterated the importance of SOCIALISM; where the organizing of working class were arduous task. He understood the actual spirit of MARXISM. In the same book, Com.EMS says that the class structure of PEOPLES DEMOCRACY will be same of BOURGEOIS DEMOCRACY. For BOURGEOIS CLASS STRUCTURE we are called as CAPITALISM. So according to LENIN; our PEOPLES DEMOCRACY is only "WAGE SLAVERY". I have doubt about our leaders that any of them had read or noticed the above version of Lenin. By saying that we are following "Marxism; Leninism" we should have follow anything ideas of Marx and Lenin; otherwise our claims will not function. The population of India is above 125 crores; and we can count why Indian working class neglecting or reluctant to admit our movement and they are not ready to vote us. As long as our target is to promote capitalism; (there is no socialism)(in what name is not the problem) Indian working class will not admit a "wage slavery system"; because they are not fools. So I request please take steps to change our PROGRAMME as a SOCIALIST INDIA and then only our movement is on actual Marxism, then only we have a target to be achieved; surely MARXISM will show its real force in India as had done in old Soviet Union and China. Since 1950s there are no target to be achieved before Indian Working Class; as "capitalism" cannot be considered as a target. In India; we can avoid only armed revolution; as a strong PARLIAMENTARY system is prevailing; but this facility was not prevailing in old Russia. We can avoid only armed revolution; but hooliganism and rowdyism must be handled on the same coins. As long as we are continuing the concept to promote Indian capitalism; our "PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC REVOLUTION" is only "WAGE SLAVERY" and Indian working class or poor peoples will not co-operate with us. As long as our stand to promote capitalism continues; will help only COMMUNAL FORCES and INDIAN AND FOREIGN CORPORATES; we will not reach anywhere.
Can you understand anything what Budhadeb had done in West Bengal; I mean that capturing land from 9000 farmers and giving them to TATA for starting a Car project? And during 1957; EMS ministry of Kerala invited BIRLA to Kerala (MAVOOR RAYONS) and started BIRLA's firm at Mavoor, Kerala (Kozhikode). These was on the decisions of the leaders of SA DANGE etc. to promote capitalism during 1950s. During that period; then leaders decided to postpone SOCIALISM and to promote capitalism. Then their decision was only for a short period; but later; unfortunately; that decision was considered for ever. They were kept the decision as "TACTICS"; but, MARXISM VANISHED FROM THE FIELD. I mean; class struggle became impossible between bourgeois and working class.
Please see my Blog No.125 also (125. AT PRESENT WHAT IS "PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC REVOLUTION"? In a book of Com.EMS, (ARTS & SCIENCE OF WORKING CLASS POLITICS) (Page 53) he says that Lenin severely criticising BOURGEOIS PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM and that implementing SOCIALISM through PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM is impossible and even social changes are impossible. Here Com. EMS had happened a mistake that Lenin (In the book STATE AND REVOLUTION") actually criticising CAPITALISM and Lenin says that even "A best PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM" will be only a "WAGE SLAVERY" (WAGE COOLIE) to working class. What is "wage slavery"? In old slavery system, slaves had the benefit of protection like cattles such as food (only capable to their existences) and shelter and in capitalism, bourgeois have not such responsibilities; but the worker should work under any bourgeois to his existences and at present he has the freedom to choice to whom he can sell his manpower; otherwise he must die. Com.EMS says in the same book; (Page 21) the necessity of "FREE DEVELOPMENT OF CAPITALISM" by severe blow on FEUDALISM. Com.EMS understood only that the words of Lenin relates to PARLIAMENTARY ELECTION PROCEDURES AND FORMING OF MINISTRY only. Lenin had decided to establish SOCIALISM in the dynasty of Tsar' where FEUDALISM IN ITS ALL EVILNESS and also the CAPITALISM of then Russia was in a pathetic condition only. Lenin was not ready to admit CAPITALISM even in that condition and reiterated the importance of SOCIALISM; where the organizing of working class were arduous task. He understood the actual spirit of MARXISM. In the same book, Com.EMS says that the class structure of PEOPLES DEMOCRACY will be same of BOURGEOIS DEMOCRACY. For BOURGEOIS CLASS STRUCTURE we are called as CAPITALISM. So according to LENIN; our PEOPLES DEMOCRACY is only "WAGE SLAVERY". I have doubt about our leaders that any of them had read or noticed the above version of Lenin. By saying that we are following "Marxism; Leninism" we should have follow anything ideas of Marx and Lenin; otherwise our claims will not function. The population of India is above 125 crores; and we can count why Indian working class neglecting or reluctant to admit our movement and they are not ready to vote us. As long as our target is to promote capitalism; (there is no socialism)(in what name is not the problem) Indian working class will not admit a "wage slavery system"; because they are not fools. So I request please take steps to change our PROGRAMME as a SOCIALIST INDIA and then only our movement is on actual Marxism, then only we have a target to be achieved; surely MARXISM will show its real force in India as had done in old Soviet Union and China. Since 1950s there are no target to be achieved before Indian Working Class; as "capitalism" cannot be considered as a target. In India; we can avoid only armed revolution; as a strong PARLIAMENTARY system is prevailing; but this facility was not prevailing in old Russia. We can avoid only armed revolution; but hooliganism and rowdyism must be handled on the same coins. As long as we are continuing the concept to promote Indian capitalism; our "PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC REVOLUTION" is only "WAGE SLAVERY" and Indian working class or poor peoples will not co-operate with us. As long as our stand to promote capitalism continues; will help only COMMUNAL FORCES and INDIAN AND FOREIGN CORPORATES; we will not reach anywhere.
അഭിപ്രായങ്ങളൊന്നുമില്ല:
ഒരു അഭിപ്രായം പോസ്റ്റ് ചെയ്യൂ